Solar calibration // generated element record

Iron Appendix

Fe I · measured products, uncertainty and reproducible evidence

Fe.json v1.223 · 130 Fe I products · 160 total

Solar Fe I anchor: 7.477 ± 0.052

HARPS · Reference Grade · Amarsi 3D-NLTE · n = 21. The selected Fe I product anchors this Solar appendix; products and engines are not averaged together.

Highlighted band products

near-UV

7.565 ± 0.129

Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · n = 56

Uncertainty budget closed for six of eight rows (RYA-1226); two Fe I Kitt Peak/molecfit rows keep a legacy bar pending their microturbulence bracket. On the migrated rows most of the quoted systematic is a conservative profile-width term carried from a measurement in another band.

VIS

7.504 ± 0.049

Kitt Peak Molecfit · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · Reference Grade · n = 21

VIS

7.477 ± 0.052

HARPS · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · Reference Grade · n = 21

red-optical

7.498 ± 0.059

Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · n = 69

NIR

7.487 ± 0.087

Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · n = 6

H

7.523 ± 0.092

CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · n = 19

Error-bar forest

How to read this forest. Each measured row is a separate abundance product for an instrument, holding, line pool and treatment; engines are never averaged together. Solid bars show statistical uncertainty from the line measurements; wireframes show systematic uncertainty from the product’s adopted error budget, which does not average away with more lines. Green and gold regions mark the Asplund and Lodders literature values and uncertainties, not pass/fail gates. Grades describe the line pool’s provenance and selection, not the quality of an engine. Reddish-orange mean-3D / Frankenstein rows are experimental and not adopted. Unmeasured model rows remain N/A.

Grades and model labels
  • Reference Grade. An externally published reference line pool, using that reference’s line selection and oscillator strengths; the current Fe reference products use AGSS21. This is a provenance category, not a promise that every line has an individual primary-laboratory uncertainty.
  • Codex Grade. The vetted Codex pool of primary-laboratory oscillator strengths, restricted to lines at or below the adopted feature-depth gate.
  • Deep Grade. The corresponding laboratory-data pool above that depth gate. These stronger lines extend coverage but require particular care with saturation and blends.

1D-LTE uses a one-dimensional atmosphere with atomic populations in local thermodynamic equilibrium. 1D-NLTE allows departures from that equilibrium; the named implementation supplies the correction or synthesis treatment.

3D-NLTE (Amarsi) includes three-dimensional atmospheric structure and non-LTE line formation; these products apply the published Amarsi correction grid to a 1D baseline.

Mean-3D / Frankenstein combines a spatially and temporally averaged 3D atmosphere with the Gerber synthesis route. Averaging removes the full 3D fluctuations and velocity field; this experimental hybrid is not a full 3D calculation or an adopted engine.

Synthesis fits the spectral line profile. EW infers abundance from a line’s integrated absorption (equivalent width). See Methodology for the full model, line-selection and uncertainty procedures.

Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 7.46 ± 0.04Lodders+ 2025 7.49 ± 0.01
blue solid = statistical σwireframe = systematic σblue = regular model resultreddish orange = experimental Frankenstein / Gerber mean-3D; not adoptedgreen = Asplund; gold = LoddersN/A = no product for this model
near-UV
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Codex deep poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · DEEPGRADED (no graded product in this band)
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEDeep Grade · n=557.554 ±0.061 stat ±0.116 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerberno productN/A
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannDeep Grade · n=557.562 ±0.061 stat ±0.116 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=567.560 ±0.061 stat ±0.122 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=567.565 ±0.054 stat ±0.117 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=567.569 ±0.061 stat ±0.122 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Codex deep poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED (no graded product in this band)
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEDeep Grade · n=547.508 ±0.064 stat ±0.117 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerberno productN/A
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannDeep Grade · n=547.516 ±0.064 stat ±0.117 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=557.512 ±0.065 stat ±0.124 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=577.467 ±0.052 stat ±0.118 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=557.518 ±0.065 stat ±0.124 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
7.327.427.527.627.72A(Fe) dex
VIS
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Codex graded poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected
EW · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=13 · 1 alternate7.445 ±0.062 stat ±0.083 syst
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=677.442 ±0.019 stat ±0.081 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=677.439 ±0.021 stat ±0.063 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=127.455 ±0.067 stat ±0.084 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=617.448 ±0.019 stat ±0.081 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=677.488 ±0.020 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · stagger · Frankenstein (experimental)Codex Grade · n=677.541 ±0.020 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · stagger · Frankenstein (experimental)Codex Grade · n=677.562 ±0.020 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfCodex Grade · n=507.505 ±0.022 stat ±0.058 syst
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=1757.435 ±0.015 stat ±0.082 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=1767.436 ±0.015 stat ±0.078 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=1657.441 ±0.015 stat ±0.082 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=1767.481 ±0.015 stat ±0.078 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfReference Grade · n=1017.485 ±0.016 stat ±0.045 syst
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Codex graded poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=137.463 ±0.062 stat ±0.092 syst
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=677.447 ±0.020 stat ±0.081 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=677.451 ±0.021 stat ±0.063 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=127.464 ±0.066 stat ±0.091 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=617.454 ±0.020 stat ±0.082 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=677.497 ±0.022 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · stagger · Frankenstein (experimental)Codex Grade · n=677.552 ±0.022 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · stagger · Frankenstein (experimental)Codex Grade · n=677.552 ±0.022 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfCodex Grade · n=507.512 ±0.022 stat ±0.058 syst
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=1757.432 ±0.015 stat ±0.080 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=1767.446 ±0.015 stat ±0.081 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=1657.442 ±0.015 stat ±0.080 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=1767.487 ±0.015 stat ±0.079 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfReference Grade · n=1017.492 ±0.016 stat ±0.045 syst
HARPS Codex graded poolsolar_harps_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=6 · 1 alternate7.498 ±0.070 stat ±0.097 syst
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=677.511 ±0.020 stat ±0.083 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=677.509 ±0.021 stat ±0.083 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=57.433 ±0.077 stat ±0.095 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=617.504 ±0.020 stat ±0.083 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=677.545 ±0.020 stat ±0.083 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfCodex Grade · n=507.512 ±0.024 stat ±0.058 syst
HARPS Reference poolsolar_harps_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=1747.514 ±0.020 stat ±0.082 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=1757.521 ±0.021 stat ±0.086 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=1647.525 ±0.021 stat ±0.081 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=1757.549 ±0.021 stat ±0.081 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfReference Grade · n=1007.500 ±0.017 stat ±0.045 syst
IAG Codex graded poolsolar_iag
EW · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=57.498 ±0.044 stat ±0.093 syst
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=437.494 ±0.023 stat ±0.080 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=437.492 ±0.023 stat ±0.087 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=47.481 ±0.019 stat ±0.089 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=377.480 ±0.023 stat ±0.080 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=437.549 ±0.023 stat ±0.083 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfCodex Grade · n=397.543 ±0.025 stat ±0.056 syst
IAG Reference poolsolar_iag
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=847.463 ±0.018 stat ±0.074 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=847.469 ±0.017 stat ±0.076 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=747.455 ±0.018 stat ±0.074 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=847.517 ±0.018 stat ±0.075 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfReference Grade · n=787.516 ±0.019 stat ±0.044 syst
7.317.407.497.577.66A(Fe) dex
red-optical
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Codex graded poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=697.458 ±0.017 stat ±0.069 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=697.454 ±0.016 stat ±0.057 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=357.451 ±0.017 stat ±0.071 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=697.498 ±0.016 stat ±0.057 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=697.458 ±0.017 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=697.454 ±0.016 stat ±0.074 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=357.451 ±0.017 stat ±0.073 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=697.498 ±0.016 stat ±0.071 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Codex graded poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=537.484 ±0.029 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=537.478 ±0.028 stat ±0.055 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=277.493 ±0.025 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=537.507 ±0.029 stat ±0.055 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=537.484 ±0.029 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=537.478 ±0.028 stat ±0.073 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=277.493 ±0.025 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=537.507 ±0.029 stat ±0.068 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
IAG Codex graded poolsolar_iag
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=687.448 ±0.024 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=687.453 ±0.024 stat ±0.070 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=357.460 ±0.041 stat ±0.074 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=687.491 ±0.024 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
IAG Reference poolsolar_iag
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=687.448 ±0.024 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=687.453 ±0.024 stat ±0.070 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=357.460 ±0.041 stat ±0.073 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=687.491 ±0.024 stat ±0.070 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
7.357.417.487.547.61A(Fe) dex
NIR
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Codex graded poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=237.515 ±0.086 stat ±0.061 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — Kurucz 2005 corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=237.519 ±0.086 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=237.510 ±0.086 stat ±0.064 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=67.390 ±0.177 stat ±0.061 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Codex graded poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=237.607 ±0.080 stat ±0.065 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=237.601 ±0.080 stat ±0.063 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=67.488 ±0.059 stat ±0.065 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
Kitt Peak — 1984 Molecfit corrected Reference poolsolar_kpno_molecfit_corrected
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=237.607 ±0.080 stat ±0.065 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=237.601 ±0.080 stat ±0.066 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=67.487 ±0.059 stat ±0.064 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
IAG Codex graded poolsolar_iag
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=257.546 ±0.159 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=227.549 ±0.069 stat ±0.064 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=67.599 ±0.072 stat ±0.063 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
IAG Reference poolsolar_iag
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=227.554 ±0.065 stat ±0.065 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=227.549 ±0.069 stat ±0.064 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=67.599 ±0.072 stat ±0.065 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
CRIRES+ Codex graded poolsolar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=57.551 ±0.062 stat ±0.062 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=57.553 ±0.062 stat ±0.062 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannCodex Grade · n=27.492 ±0.070 stat ±0.061 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
CRIRES+ Reference poolsolar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=57.546 ±0.062 stat ±0.062 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=57.554 ±0.062 stat ±0.062 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · BergemannReference Grade · n=27.486 ±0.069 stat ±0.061 syst
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerberno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
7.187.327.467.607.73A(Fe) dex
H
CRIRES+ Codex graded poolsolar_crires_plus_h_rya1094
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTECodex Grade · n=207.552 ±0.087 stat ±0.079 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=197.523 ±0.051 stat ±0.076 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberCodex Grade · n=97.549 ±0.070 stat ±0.073 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
CRIRES+ Reference poolsolar_crires_plus_h_rya1094
EW · 1D-LTEno productN/A
Synth · 1D-LTEReference Grade · n=207.552 ±0.087 stat ±0.079 syst
Synth · 1D-LTE · GerberReference Grade · n=197.518 ±0.052 stat ±0.076 syst
EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemannno productN/A
Synth · 1D-NLTE · GerberReference Grade · n=97.549 ±0.070 stat ±0.073 syst
Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · staggerno productN/A
Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gfno productN/A
7.397.467.537.607.67A(Fe) dex
Read all product values, including alternate line sets and experiments
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.552 ± 0.118 reported total; n=20; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.549 ± 0.102 reported total; n=9; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.523 ± 0.092 reported total; n=19; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.552 ± 0.118 reported total; n=20; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.549 ± 0.102 reported total; n=9; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.518 ± 0.092 reported total; n=19; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054 · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.551 ± 0.087 reported total; n=5; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054 · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.492 ± 0.093 reported total; n=2; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054 · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.553 ± 0.088 reported total; n=5; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054 · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.546 ± 0.088 reported total; n=5; ξ MEASURED
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054 · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.486 ± 0.092 reported total; n=2; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • CRIRES+ · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054 · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.554 ± 0.088 reported total; n=5; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.546 ± 0.171 reported total; n=25; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.599 ± 0.095 reported total; n=6; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.549 ± 0.094 reported total; n=22; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.554 ± 0.092 reported total; n=22; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.599 ± 0.097 reported total; n=6; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.549 ± 0.094 reported total; n=22; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.515 ± 0.105 reported total; n=23; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.519 ± 0.106 reported total; n=23; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.390 ± 0.187 reported total; n=6; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.510 ± 0.107 reported total; n=23; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.607 ± 0.104 reported total; n=23; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.488 ± 0.087 reported total; n=6; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.601 ± 0.102 reported total; n=23; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.607 ± 0.103 reported total; n=23; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.487 ± 0.087 reported total; n=6; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.601 ± 0.103 reported total; n=23; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ASPLUND_AGSS21 · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.477 ± 0.052 reported total; n=21; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-LTE · Deep Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED-LOCALRENORM · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.339 ± 0.087 reported total; n=109; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Deep Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED-LOCALRENORM · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.350 ± 0.088 reported total; n=105; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-LTE · Deep Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.535 ± 0.093 reported total; n=109; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Deep Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.554 ± 0.094 reported total; n=105; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · EW · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · 1D-LTE: 7.498 ± 0.120 reported total; n=6; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · ENGINE-A: 7.433 ± 0.123 reported total; n=5; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · EW · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · ENGINE-B: 7.431 ± 0.122 reported total; n=5; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.511 ± 0.086 reported total; n=67; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.512 ± 0.062 reported total; n=50; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.504 ± 0.086 reported total; n=61; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.545 ± 0.086 reported total; n=67; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.509 ± 0.086 reported total; n=67; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.514 ± 0.084 reported total; n=174; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.500 ± 0.048 reported total; n=100; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.525 ± 0.084 reported total; n=164; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.549 ± 0.083 reported total; n=175; ξ MEASURED
  • HARPS · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.521 ± 0.089 reported total; n=175; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_iag · ASPLUND_AGSS21 · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.504 ± 0.050 reported total; n=21; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Deep Grade · solar_iag · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.416 ± 0.071 reported total; n=41; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Deep Grade · solar_iag · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.422 ± 0.070 reported total; n=37; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · EW · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · 1D-LTE: 7.498 ± 0.102 reported total; n=5; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · ENGINE-A: 7.481 ± 0.091 reported total; n=4; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.494 ± 0.083 reported total; n=43; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.543 ± 0.061 reported total; n=39; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.480 ± 0.083 reported total; n=37; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.549 ± 0.087 reported total; n=43; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.492 ± 0.090 reported total; n=43; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.463 ± 0.076 reported total; n=84; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.516 ± 0.047 reported total; n=78; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.455 ± 0.076 reported total; n=74; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.517 ± 0.077 reported total; n=84; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.469 ± 0.078 reported total; n=84; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · ASPLUND_AGSS21 · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.471 ± 0.049 reported total; n=21; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.421 ± 0.086 reported total; n=108; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.431 ± 0.086 reported total; n=104; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · EW · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · 1D-LTE: 7.445 ± 0.104 reported total; n=13; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · ENGINE-A: 7.455 ± 0.107 reported total; n=12; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · EW · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · ENGINE-B: 7.479 ± 0.090 reported total; n=9; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.442 ± 0.084 reported total; n=67; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.505 ± 0.062 reported total; n=50; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.448 ± 0.084 reported total; n=61; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.488 ± 0.066 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.439 ± 0.067 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · stagger · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-mean3D-LTE-gerber-stagger: 7.541 ± 0.067 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND. · experimental, not adopted
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · stagger · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-mean3D-NLTE-gerber-stagger: 7.562 ± 0.066 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND. · experimental, not adopted
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.435 ± 0.083 reported total; n=175; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.485 ± 0.048 reported total; n=101; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.441 ± 0.083 reported total; n=165; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.481 ± 0.080 reported total; n=176; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.436 ± 0.080 reported total; n=176; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · ASPLUND_AGSS21 · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.504 ± 0.049 reported total; n=21; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.417 ± 0.045 reported total; n=108; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.426 ± 0.084 reported total; n=104; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · EW · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · 1D-LTE: 7.463 ± 0.111 reported total; n=13; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · EW · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · PROFILEFIT · ENGINE-A: 7.464 ± 0.112 reported total; n=12; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.447 ± 0.084 reported total; n=67; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.512 ± 0.062 reported total; n=50; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.454 ± 0.085 reported total; n=61; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.497 ± 0.067 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.451 ± 0.067 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · <3D>-LTE · Gerber · stagger · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-mean3D-LTE-gerber-stagger: 7.552 ± 0.067 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND. · experimental, not adopted
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · <3D>-NLTE · Gerber · stagger · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-mean3D-NLTE-gerber-stagger: 7.552 ± 0.067 reported total; n=67; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND. · experimental, not adopted
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.432 ± 0.082 reported total; n=175; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi · lab-gf · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A-3DNLTE: 7.492 ± 0.048 reported total; n=101; ξ NOT_APPLICABLE
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.442 ± 0.082 reported total; n=165; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.487 ± 0.081 reported total; n=176; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.446 ± 0.083 reported total; n=176; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.554 ± 0.245 reported total; n=55; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.562 ± 0.248 reported total; n=55; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.560 ± 0.136 reported total; n=56; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.569 ± 0.136 reported total; n=56; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.565 ± 0.129 reported total; n=56; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.508 ± 0.133 reported total; n=54; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Deep Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · DEEPGRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.516 ± 0.133 reported total; n=54; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.512 ± 0.140 reported total; n=55; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.518 ± 0.140 reported total; n=55; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.467 ± 0.129 reported total; n=57; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.448 ± 0.074 reported total; n=68; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.460 ± 0.084 reported total; n=35; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.491 ± 0.074 reported total; n=68; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_iag · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.453 ± 0.074 reported total; n=68; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.448 ± 0.074 reported total; n=68; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.460 ± 0.084 reported total; n=35; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.491 ± 0.074 reported total; n=68; ξ MEASURED
  • IAG · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_iag · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.453 ± 0.074 reported total; n=68; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.458 ± 0.071 reported total; n=69; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.451 ± 0.073 reported total; n=35; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.498 ± 0.059 reported total; n=69; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.454 ± 0.059 reported total; n=69; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.458 ± 0.072 reported total; n=69; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.451 ± 0.075 reported total; n=35; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.498 ± 0.072 reported total; n=69; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.454 ± 0.076 reported total; n=69; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.484 ± 0.075 reported total; n=53; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.493 ± 0.075 reported total; n=27; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.507 ± 0.062 reported total; n=53; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Codex Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · GRADED · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.478 ± 0.062 reported total; n=53; ξ UNMEASURED · INCOMPLETE: no dA/dxi exists for this pool, so the xi term is absent from this bar rather than zero. The bar is a LOWER BOUND.
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · 1D-LTE: 7.484 ± 0.076 reported total; n=53; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Bergemann · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-A: 7.493 ± 0.075 reported total; n=27; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · ENGINE-B-NLTE: 7.507 ± 0.074 reported total; n=53; ξ MEASURED
  • Kitt Peak · Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber · Reference Grade · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · REFERENCE · SYNTH · synth-1D-LTE-gerber: 7.478 ± 0.078 reported total; n=53; ξ MEASURED

Solar iron context

Fe I supplies the bulk of the neutral-iron line statistics used for the Solar abundance reference. Separate instruments, line pools and treatments test the stability of that reference; their differences remain visible.

Near-UV opacity — report and noted

Molecular opacity INCLUDED — OH A-X, NH, CH and CN violet, 6,223 VALD lines as Turbospectrum lists with the dominant isotopologue (RYA-1207). The band previously carried none: every molecular list iSpec ships begins at 400 nm. Measured PAIRED against a molecules-off run on the same code and pool, the lever is -0.047..-0.055 dex on Fe I and -0.276..-0.332 on Fe II, with chi2r median 81.8 -> 67.4 and control windows containing no molecular line bit-identical. RYA-1209 additionally curated out Fe I 3721.272 (systematic:K07 — gf attributed to a VALD3 reference that publishes no per-line uncertainty, no NIST accuracy class, so it never met the DEEPGRADED tier's lab-gf definition); the Fe I pool is 57 candidates and the budget clears at gf rung 3 (cited lab), 55/55 GF-LAB, RMS 0.0509 dex. RESIDUAL DEFICIT: the correction still UNDER-corrects — RYA-1204 measured synth/obs above 1 on 24 of 40 windows after it — so the band remains short of opacity by an amount not yet measured on this pool, and these values are a floor rather than a converged answer. sigma_syst is unchanged at 0.1122 because it is dominated by the 0.10 dex pseudo-continuum term, not by gf: the true continuum is never observed here. Not adopted for the headline. The headline is the per-band best-available product, selected from this feed by the publication generator rather than fixed as a constant: RYA-850 promoted the graded laboratory-gf pool to the PRIMARY reported value, and RYA-819 retired the earlier constructed anchor after showing its Magic-2013 correction wrong in both magnitude and shape. RYA-161: nothing calibrated to a target.

Frankenstein — experimental, pending the Bride

4 experimental products remain available in the Fe I product values and downloads.

RYA-1197 Part A: the Frankenstein mean-<3D> route is HELD FROM HEADLINE publication until the Bride validates it. It inflates A(Fe) by roughly +0.10 dex against the 1D siblings and exists on VIS/KP only, so it is not a comparable measurement of the same quantity. It stays in the feed deliberately: the LTE/NLTE mean-3D PAIR is the NLTE differential on ONE atmosphere (RYA-542), which is the diagnostic it is for. Not a headline value.

Problem-line and model diagnostics

CH G-band artifact

CH G-band artifact
CH G-band blend artifact — the synthesis list cannot represent the dominant absorber · A = 10.0 (+2.5 dex). RYA-1191 blend audit: 66 catalogued transitions in the 0.62 A fit window, top contaminant CH I at 43.8% of the summed depth against Fe II's 11.1%. The VIS synthesis list GESv6_atom_hfs_iso carries 206 species and NOT ONE molecular, so the fit had nowhere to put the CH absorption except Fe II. RYA-515 independently counted 36 of 65 transitions as CH. The plot shows the committed transition census in the proof generator’s fit window; it is not a synthetic spectrum. Source evidence

Near-UV molecular opacity

Near-UV molecular opacity
molecules OFF vs ON on THE SAME CODE and the same pool. Differencing against the published values instead would have measured the molecular lever PLUS every code change since the feed was written on Sept 3 -- which is about -0.035 dex of the total. Source evidence

HARPS arm offset

HARPS arm offset
Current Fe II VIS products, separated by holding and engine. The arm offset persists after the curated CH artifact was removed. Source evidence

CRIRES+ H model coverage

CRIRES+ H model coverage
Included and excluded line counts from each current product. Excluded rows are not automatically failed fits; the per-line reason distinguishes unavailable NLTE coverage. Source evidence

Download the evidence

Download PDF — Solar Fe I appendix

6686 graded per-line measurements exported. Evidence for 22 graded products is missing or does not reproduce the feed; 0 exported lines lack an unambiguous gf match. The download is explicitly incomplete until those upstream records are supplied.

Reproducibility

Generator scripts/generate_fe_publication.py v1.0.0
Science source commit 74217457b5a004eac983f9e34eb23d5fc4b89fd7
Fe.json v1.223 · feed timestamp 2026-09-24T16:11:18Z
Generated 2026-09-24T16:34:16+00:00
Feed SHA-256 140e81ffc805708f97f1a1caede872c40cd5eef3e05580211ecf0ee6a0e72728

Refreshed product tracker · Build manifest · Fe II appendix

References