Carbon Appendix

• quarantine · C · I · VIS · harps · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ALL · SET-AGSS21 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · harps · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ALL · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · ALL · SET-AGSS21 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · ALL · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · ALL · SET-AGSS21 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · ALL · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · iag_fts_solar_atlas · solar_iag · ALL · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · red-optical · iag_fts_solar_atlas · solar_iag · ALL · SET-AGSS21 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · red-optical · iag_fts_solar_atlas · solar_iag · ALL · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · red-optical · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · ALL · SET-AGSS21 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · red-optical · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · ALL · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · red-optical · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · ALL · SET-AGSS21 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · red-optical · kpno_solar_atlas · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · ALL · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · harps · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ALL · MOL-CH_Gband · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [STAT_BASIS_MISMATCH] sigma_stat here is a 'curvature_sigma' (SYNTH route, band_products.py:506) while the rest of the feed publishes a 'standard_error' (error_budget.py:609). The feed carries no stat_basis field, so `A +/- sigma_stat` renders as comparable when it is not -- this product's bar reads ~sqrt(n) times worse than it is. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · harps · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ALL · ATOM-CI_5052 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [STAT_BASIS_MISMATCH] sigma_stat here is a 'curvature_sigma' (SYNTH route, band_products.py:506) while the rest of the feed publishes a 'standard_error' (error_budget.py:609). The feed carries no stat_basis field, so `A +/- sigma_stat` renders as comparable when it is not -- this product's bar reads ~sqrt(n) times worse than it is. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · harps · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ALL · ATOM-CI_5380 · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [STAT_BASIS_MISMATCH] sigma_stat here is a 'curvature_sigma' (SYNTH route, band_products.py:506) while the rest of the feed publishes a 'standard_error' (error_budget.py:609). The feed carries no stat_basis field, so `A +/- sigma_stat` renders as comparable when it is not -- this product's bar reads ~sqrt(n) times worse than it is. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.
• quarantine · C · I · VIS · harps · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ALL · MOL-C2_Swan · SYNTH · 1D-LTE
  RYA-1097 gated re-run precedence: this product does NOT pass the RYA-1092 eligibility gate, so it was published into quarantine and did not supersede anything. [STAT_BASIS_MISMATCH] sigma_stat here is a 'curvature_sigma' (SYNTH route, band_products.py:506) while the rest of the feed publishes a 'standard_error' (error_budget.py:609). The feed carries no stat_basis field, so `A +/- sigma_stat` renders as comparable when it is not -- this product's bar reads ~sqrt(n) times worse than it is. [NOT_YET_DEFENSIBLE] C I is outside the ratified real set {Fe I, Fe II, Al}. It is a pilot measurement, not a product.

Solar abundance and indicator analyses. Solar C atomic/molecular indicator lineage and atmospheric sensitivity; comparison literature, not an adopted Codex abundance. Sources: [1], [2].

Atomic data and gf authorities. The recorded C I/II pedigree is the partial NIST MCHF update described by Wiese & Fuhr; evaluated theory is not primary laboratory evidence. Sources: [3], [4].

Atomic data and gf authorities. AGSS21 names Li et al. for its C I gf lineage. This reference calculation is distinct from the campaign’s NIST/MCHF adjudication; no gf source is substituted here. Sources: [5].

Model and grid sources. Registered C I line/grid lineage: Amarsi, Nissen & Skuladottir 2019, A&A 630, A104 — line-by-line 3D-NLTE / 1D-NLTE grids (CDS J/A+A/630/A104). The current feed treatment remains authoritative; a grid reference does not imply a correction was applied. Sources: [6].

Atomic data and gf authorities. Atomic C I entry; source-family pedigree only, not a substitute for a per-transition gf join. Sources: [3], [4].

Model and grid sources. Feed treatment: 1D-LTE; no NLTE/3D correction is claimed for this entry. Turbospectrum is the synthesis implementation. Sources: [7].

Molecular line data and delivery. CH line-data delivery: CH A-X: Masseron et al. 2014 (MNRAS 442, 1489) / 2022 update. Masseron compilation, VALD-based, distributed with iSpec/Turbospectrum (Gerber et al. 2023, A&A 669, A43; uploaded 2022 to keeper.mpdl.mpg.de, split per wavelength region) — see molecules-dir README.md The primary intake identifies Masseron 2014 as A&A 571 A47; the older delivery manifest’s MNRAS locator conflicts with that record. Sources: [2], [7], [8].

Molecular line data and delivery. C2 line-data delivery: C2 Swan d³Πg–a³Πu (Brooke et al. 2013 / Masseron compilation). Masseron compilation, VALD-based, distributed with iSpec/Turbospectrum (Gerber et al. 2023, A&A 669, A43; uploaded 2022 to keeper.mpdl.mpg.de, split per wavelength region) — see molecules-dir README.md Sources: [2], [7], [9].

• C-quarantine-d336fe3e3260 · quarantine · VIS · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · SET-AGSS21 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-41dc4d995d0a · quarantine · VIS · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · not supplied · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-d7f7f2d3feb3 · quarantine · VIS · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · SET-AGSS21 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-639e603cf7be · quarantine · VIS · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · not supplied · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-2aa4ddfc06a1 · quarantine · VIS · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · SET-AGSS21 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-9b3b9069e4e7 · quarantine · VIS · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · not supplied · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-3bc9c9cad7eb · quarantine · VIS · solar_iag · not supplied · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-355831cbb1ba · quarantine · red-optical · solar_iag · SET-AGSS21 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-4fbb94c006f5 · quarantine · red-optical · solar_iag · not supplied · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-fcfcfcb6a7f1 · quarantine · red-optical · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · SET-AGSS21 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-7dc0d38da697 · quarantine · red-optical · solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected · not supplied · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-cfe54788e705 · quarantine · red-optical · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · SET-AGSS21 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-f3b6b9c248bd · quarantine · red-optical · solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected · not supplied · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-a9c721228e27 · quarantine · VIS · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · MOL-CH_Gband · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [2], [7], [8]
• C-quarantine-886af3241708 · quarantine · VIS · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ATOM-CI_5052 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-801532fb2d97 · quarantine · VIS · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · ATOM-CI_5380 · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [3], [4], [7]
• C-quarantine-1c1b6ac111e3 · quarantine · VIS · solar_harps_molecfit_corrected · MOL-C2_Swan · 1D-LTE · not supplied · [1], [2], [7], [9]

Solar abundance and indicator analyses

• [1] — Asplund, M.; Amarsi, A. M.; Grevesse, N. (2021). The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision. A&A 653, A141 DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202140445. source record
• [2] — Amarsi et al. 2021, A&A 656 A113 DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202141384. source record

Atomic data and gf authorities

• [3] — Kramida, A.; Ralchenko, Yu.; Reader, J.; NIST ASD Team (2024). NIST Atomic Spectra Database (version 5.11/5.12). National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD DOI: 10.18434/T4W30F. source record
• [4] — Wiese, W. L.; Fuhr, J. R. (2006). New Critical Compilations of Atomic Transition Probabilities for Neutral and Singly Ionized Carbon, Nitrogen, and Iron. Proceedings of the NASA Laboratory Astrophysics Workshop (14-16 February 2006, UNLV, Las Vegas) source record
• [5] — Li, Amarsi, Papoulia, Ekman & Jonsson 2021, MNRAS 502, 3780 DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stab214. source record

Model and grid sources

• [6] — Amarsi, A. M.; Nissen, P. E.; Skuladottir, A. (2019). Carbon, oxygen, and iron abundances in disk and halo stars. A&A 630, A104 DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/201936265. source record
• [7] — Gerber, J. M.; Magg, E.; Plez, B.; Bergemann, M.; Heiter, U.; Olander, T.; Hoppe, R. (2023). Non-LTE radiative transfer with Turbospectrum. A&A 669, A43 DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202243673. source record

Molecular line data and delivery

• [8] — Masseron et al. 2014, A&A 571 A47 DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/201423956. source record
• [9] — Brooke et al. 2013, JQSRT 124, 11 DOI: 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2013.02.025. source record