{
  "schema": "codex.element_appendix/1",
  "title": "Solar Na appendix",
  "target": "Sun",
  "element": "Na",
  "ion": "",
  "site_url": "https://exoplanetcodex.org/systems/sol/elements/na/",
  "metadata": {
    "generator": "scripts/generate_cno_publication.py",
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "source_commit": "e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71",
    "source_url": "https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71",
    "generated_at": "2026-11-05T21:50:45-07:00",
    "timestamp_basis": "source commit timestamp (deterministic build)",
    "feed_version": "1.158",
    "feed_updated_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:12Z",
    "feed_sha256": "f402244800e12a2ce57c1ea71a7eb122e2d3eb378beb0172c55e56483438bfb8",
    "source_sha256": {
      "data/products/solar/Na.json": "f402244800e12a2ce57c1ea71a7eb122e2d3eb378beb0172c55e56483438bfb8",
      "data/refs/bibliography.csv": "de8965bb277b5c8f9dbae22f4dfe496b5ff5b909df7b09fe42ddce84515ca37c",
      "data/catalog/holdings_manifest_registry.csv": "4498f11d539efa251eb50be8851ca45de2a96b4e0634f293df55d279c23be13d",
      "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv": "01bf38b20cbc5f0c9892612aef489e37da8c287a4366335801ed427e6c516dd0",
      "data/reference/gf_error_model.csv": "f3581797aba88381f8ba1c52eba355d2d898fec680a104b680396bae0d25c875",
      "data/reference/litscan/Na.yaml": "c662b75befac2c9dcc2dc7c619c38f64ac1720564e3a59cc4a59bae9b1142605",
      "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json": "6b5cf5236100e0c051e1bf316341523534901eeacd98d44f5cbc531f76bbcdf8",
      "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv": "ac7f532164840fe5b11c1f181ad467dbf8a33a0d15dfc7edbf62958b2b4c0604",
      "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv": "2cd0d46bfd1954a99a09e4dcefcd95ec8e9dc27f909c4109565733431e3c0374",
      "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml": "3d7396fbf8622cc79f32d771e00b06a9a717be1549957345db59e72b71503f23"
    },
    "generator_sha256": "d1252936db4a865dc7532b2a1a686ba93eca6ef8efa7d87c8bd8ea076bc5efd9",
    "reference_resolver_sha256": "3503bd3745ae317c3704c0baa579068ab619075ec79562bed3ffa7a12fbd570d",
    "reference_supplement_sha256": "0001bf4e51cdfa30a8b457f437d83f5320b7c833756b322cefb2a3fb416a6d73",
    "reference_count": 6,
    "template_sha256": "da7f1fc8c75c602f080972be38be865dc92a89a65f5a0228a6b91579b7e69183",
    "highlight_selectors_sha256": "4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945",
    "pdf_generator_sha256": "be948cb041d498234ccead8280b5bdbe2526b4f776540f4e50093b985d9c5a22",
    "pdf_brand_sha256": "b8b854fc4bde7855b967369d62ac71a06e7580aa581a58c22832e43fe3ebb7f6",
    "counts": {
      "products": 87,
      "quarantine": 0,
      "archive": 69,
      "superseded": 0
    },
    "visible_products": 87,
    "dispositions": {
      "products": 87,
      "archive": 69
    },
    "highlight_selectors": [],
    "status": "products",
    "table_renderer_sha256": "b7ecb0d093761b227e8d2884d62dbe54362254ee3df3ead9eed8445e4f4b58db"
  },
  "products": [
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "H",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 5.796,
      "sigma_stat": 0.6916,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 3,
      "n_excluded": 4,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.58536 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|H|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.6915576620933355,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "n_components": 3,
              "raw_sigma": 1.1978130071092064,
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.011508644094283604,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_0578f0e9c8e2",
                "pk_c4a17593d2b0",
                "pk_1f302078b826"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013103999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 3 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0000/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.044999999999999984,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.031,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.031,
              "n_paired": 3,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.89,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.5449336458878333,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 16373.87,
                  "dA_df": -386.99999999999955,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 1.6013606471716686,
                  "sky_pair": "molecfit mtrans of H1559_o4d1 (v=+26.00 km/s, ccf 0.873)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 45,
                  "max_depth": 0.1268035017636714,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.00877674609925766,
                  "n_unverifiable_px": 0,
                  "residual_flux": 0.004137882809229123,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction (our molecfit of the Vesta IDPs, H1559_o4d1), baseline-removed, on pixels the sky absorbs"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 16388.849,
                  "dA_df": -41.999999999999815,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.06377224628166205,
                  "sky_pair": "molecfit mtrans of H1559_o4d1 (v=+26.00 km/s, ccf 0.873)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 21,
                  "max_depth": 0.03723799835407038,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0017619787138053935,
                  "n_unverifiable_px": 0,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0015183868162300554,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction (our molecfit of the Vesta IDPs, H1559_o4d1), baseline-removed, on pixels the sky absorbs"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 17038.401,
                  "dA_df": -131.99999999999966,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.3227247807026685,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1232 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 240,
                  "max_depth": 0.02517479334517614,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.00941082248035149,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_h_rya1232, baseline-removed (sky = rya1232 molecfit model: no Vesta IDP segment covers this line)",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0024448847022929495
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "H",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "16373.870": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "16388.850": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.13,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "17038.400": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.001,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.47825199999999995,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00013244888888888886,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001717148159999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009609999999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.2969526784206065,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.8814410769447356,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.8814410769447356
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_0578f0e9c8e2",
        "pk_c4a17593d2b0",
        "pk_1f302078b826"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.8814410769447356,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_15009_17491_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_15009_17491_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "4bb99061f3ba974fdf121078f975647c2dfa0d890253387926f031ca8561fab4",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T14:04:30Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T14:04:46Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.6925464099971929,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.6915576620933355,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-fb210d1eee02"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "H",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 5.779,
      "sigma_stat": 0.6919,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 3,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.58714 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|H|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.6918888601124328,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "n_components": 3,
              "raw_sigma": 1.198386658905649,
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.011508644094283604,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_0578f0e9c8e2",
                "pk_c4a17593d2b0",
                "pk_1f302078b826"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013103999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 3 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0000/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.044999999999999984,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.031,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.031,
              "n_paired": 3,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.89,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.5449336458878333,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 16373.87,
                  "dA_df": -386.99999999999955,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 1.6013606471716686,
                  "sky_pair": "molecfit mtrans of H1559_o4d1 (v=+26.00 km/s, ccf 0.873)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 45,
                  "max_depth": 0.1268035017636714,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.00877674609925766,
                  "n_unverifiable_px": 0,
                  "residual_flux": 0.004137882809229123,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction (our molecfit of the Vesta IDPs, H1559_o4d1), baseline-removed, on pixels the sky absorbs"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 16388.849,
                  "dA_df": -41.999999999999815,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.06377224628166205,
                  "sky_pair": "molecfit mtrans of H1559_o4d1 (v=+26.00 km/s, ccf 0.873)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 21,
                  "max_depth": 0.03723799835407038,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0017619787138053935,
                  "n_unverifiable_px": 0,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0015183868162300554,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction (our molecfit of the Vesta IDPs, H1559_o4d1), baseline-removed, on pixels the sky absorbs"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 17038.401,
                  "dA_df": -131.99999999999966,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.3227247807026685,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1232 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 240,
                  "max_depth": 0.02517479334517614,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.00941082248035149,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_h_rya1232, baseline-removed (sky = rya1232 molecfit model: no Vesta IDP segment covers this line)",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0024448847022929495
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0152745454545454,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "H",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "16373.870": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "16388.850": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.13,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "17038.400": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.001,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.47871019474768156,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00013244888888888886,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001717148159999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009609999999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.2969526784206065,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.8822111804285734,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.8822111804285734
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_0578f0e9c8e2",
        "pk_c4a17593d2b0",
        "pk_1f302078b826"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.8822111804285734,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_15009_17491_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_15009_17491_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "0994f41d37e07da88723ebcda25052a91af8099ec6b8ab32aa9bf6021f1050d1",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T15:00:50Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:19Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.6928771353910314,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.6918888601124328,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a80b76db5d6a"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "H",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 5.803,
      "sigma_stat": 0.7126,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 3,
      "n_excluded": 4,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.60167 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|H|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.7125593152698081,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "n_components": 3,
              "raw_sigma": 1.2341889374537973,
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.011508644094283604,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_0578f0e9c8e2",
                "pk_c4a17593d2b0",
                "pk_1f302078b826"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 3 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0000/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.031,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.031,
              "n_paired": 3,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.89,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.5919271579945412,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 16373.87,
                  "dA_df": -423.00000000000006,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 1.7503244283039192,
                  "sky_pair": "molecfit mtrans of H1559_o4d1 (v=+26.00 km/s, ccf 0.873)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 45,
                  "max_depth": 0.1268035017636714,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.00877674609925766,
                  "n_unverifiable_px": 0,
                  "residual_flux": 0.004137882809229123,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction (our molecfit of the Vesta IDPs, H1559_o4d1), baseline-removed, on pixels the sky absorbs"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 16388.849,
                  "dA_df": -40.000000000000036,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.06073547264920227,
                  "sky_pair": "molecfit mtrans of H1559_o4d1 (v=+26.00 km/s, ccf 0.873)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.027460846026314698,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 21,
                  "max_depth": 0.03723799835407038,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0017619787138053935,
                  "n_unverifiable_px": 0,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0015183868162300554,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction (our molecfit of the Vesta IDPs, H1559_o4d1), baseline-removed, on pixels the sky absorbs"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 17038.401,
                  "dA_df": -120.0000000000001,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.2933861642751542,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1232 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 240,
                  "max_depth": 0.02517479334517614,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.00941082248035149,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094 vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_h_rya1232, baseline-removed (sky = rya1232 molecfit model: no Vesta IDP segment covers this line)",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0024448847022929495
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "H",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "16373.870": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "16388.850": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.13,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "17038.400": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.001,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_h_15007_17494/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "91df4ea271319340e0430fbb4f045aa8a3031868ac6b87fd87a18e642bad2d44",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.5077407777777777,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00013244888888888886,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009609999999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.35037776037149454,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.9271895798800595,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.9271895798800595
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_0578f0e9c8e2",
        "pk_c4a17593d2b0",
        "pk_1f302078b826"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.9271895798800595,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_15009_17491_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_15009_17491_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "256139c966876335a3bfb5b81a6e49fdc8972c1b26c69ee63b8d3790bc0c1870",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T14:04:29Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T14:04:46Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.7135189610499344,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.7125593152698081,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c047829fd0f2"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "K",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 5.898,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1429,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 5,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.14289 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|K|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1428913768504989,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.37805504764203196,
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008103614713729387,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_c3424dc5ffc7",
                "pk_83afa68ad9f4",
                "pk_83b8e85c0994",
                "pk_e1d2f8403eef",
                "pk_cfdf1a8cf436",
                "pk_c6fd7bfc45ee",
                "pk_edfd5383feca"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0086,
                0.0086
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 7 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0050/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 7
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.029,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.029,
              "n_paired": 7,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 2.58,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.11840529628751108,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21323.781,
                  "dA_df": -243.0000000000003,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.006237278106552835,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21335.026,
                  "dA_df": -319.9999999999994,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0064906348711991635,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21452.374,
                  "dA_df": -28.00000000000047,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.017304675738182403,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 90,
                  "max_depth": 0.025699999999999945,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003786912582760441,
                  "residual_flux": 0.000618024133506504,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 21452.374 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 22047.273,
                  "dA_df": -208.99999999999963,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.7825391931528914,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 345,
                  "max_depth": 0.10632461487052336,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.02294244280516737,
                  "residual_flux": 0.003744206665803315,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 22047.273 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 22059.289,
                  "dA_df": -11.00000000000012,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0882952595230838,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 262,
                  "max_depth": 0.3446990576436566,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.04918407950260852,
                  "residual_flux": 0.008026841774825712,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 22059.289 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 23348.382,
                  "dA_df": -9.000000000000341,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.05041288944278637,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 400,
                  "max_depth": 0.12018372781097553,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.034322500982287896,
                  "residual_flux": 0.005601432160309385,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 23348.382 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 23379.139,
                  "dA_df": -8.000000000000007,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.2529156823107847,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 400,
                  "max_depth": 0.4810202829558673,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.19371605569147093,
                  "residual_flux": 0.03161446028884806,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 23379.139 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "K",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "21323.779": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.026,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "21335.026": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 18,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 18,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.046,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "22047.272": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.004,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "22059.289": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.008,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "23348.378": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.306,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "23379.140": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.331,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.020417945578231296,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            6.566857142857141e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0008410000000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.014019814188933284,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.1893327159119447,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.1893327159119447
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_c3424dc5ffc7",
        "pk_83afa68ad9f4",
        "pk_83b8e85c0994",
        "pk_e1d2f8403eef",
        "pk_cfdf1a8cf436",
        "pk_c6fd7bfc45ee",
        "pk_edfd5383feca"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.1893327159119447,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_19455_24842_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_19455_24842_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "aa4276948d89be4b9f2b30695be3799a8f70f9b26974b6a8481fdbff7cb1ed65",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T14:11:59Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T14:12:16Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.14760242402559418,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.1428913768504989,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0552befecb14"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "K",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 5.903,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1316,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.13164 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|K|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.13163613506594848,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.3482764769342087,
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008103614713729387,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_c3424dc5ffc7",
                "pk_83afa68ad9f4",
                "pk_83b8e85c0994",
                "pk_e1d2f8403eef",
                "pk_cfdf1a8cf436",
                "pk_c6fd7bfc45ee",
                "pk_edfd5383feca"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0086,
                0.0086
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 7 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0050/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 7
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.029,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.029,
              "n_paired": 7,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 2.58,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.11840529628751108,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21323.781,
                  "dA_df": -243.0000000000003,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.006237278106552835,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21335.026,
                  "dA_df": -319.9999999999994,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0064906348711991635,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21452.374,
                  "dA_df": -28.00000000000047,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.017304675738182403,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 90,
                  "max_depth": 0.025699999999999945,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003786912582760441,
                  "residual_flux": 0.000618024133506504,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 21452.374 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 22047.273,
                  "dA_df": -208.99999999999963,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.7825391931528914,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 345,
                  "max_depth": 0.10632461487052336,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.02294244280516737,
                  "residual_flux": 0.003744206665803315,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 22047.273 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 22059.289,
                  "dA_df": -11.00000000000012,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0882952595230838,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 262,
                  "max_depth": 0.3446990576436566,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.04918407950260852,
                  "residual_flux": 0.008026841774825712,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 22059.289 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 23348.382,
                  "dA_df": -9.000000000000341,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.05041288944278637,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 400,
                  "max_depth": 0.12018372781097553,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.034322500982287896,
                  "residual_flux": 0.005601432160309385,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 23348.382 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 23379.139,
                  "dA_df": -8.000000000000007,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.2529156823107847,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 400,
                  "max_depth": 0.4810202829558673,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.19371605569147093,
                  "residual_flux": 0.03161446028884806,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 23379.139 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": 0.0018845454545454,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "K",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "21323.779": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.026,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "21335.026": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 18,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 18,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.046,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "22047.272": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.004,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "22059.289": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.008,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "23348.378": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.306,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "23379.140": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.331,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.017328072055100632,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            6.566857142857141e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0008410000000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.014019814188933284,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.18345845249391615,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.18345845249391615
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_c3424dc5ffc7",
        "pk_83afa68ad9f4",
        "pk_83b8e85c0994",
        "pk_e1d2f8403eef",
        "pk_cfdf1a8cf436",
        "pk_c6fd7bfc45ee",
        "pk_edfd5383feca"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.18345845249391615,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_19455_24842_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_19455_24842_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "e4df336e1297f4b0addc0587aa388a9781bb4b1b6656dfd17f28e03a2e2445dd",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T15:00:51Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:19Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.13673551863031286,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.13163613506594848,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4f1dee816393"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "K",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 5.899,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1418,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 5,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.14176 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|K|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.14175733793050313,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.3750546626826549,
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008103614713729387,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_c3424dc5ffc7",
                "pk_83afa68ad9f4",
                "pk_83b8e85c0994",
                "pk_e1d2f8403eef",
                "pk_cfdf1a8cf436",
                "pk_c6fd7bfc45ee",
                "pk_edfd5383feca"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0086,
                0.0086
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013103999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 7 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0050/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.013103999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.044999999999999984,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 7
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.035,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.035,
              "n_paired": 7,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 2.58,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1123651046286079,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21323.781,
                  "dA_df": -223.00000000000074,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.006237278106552835,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21335.026,
                  "dA_df": -330.00000000000006,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0064906348711991635,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 21452.374,
                  "dA_df": -27.99999999999958,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.017304675738181854,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 90,
                  "max_depth": 0.025699999999999945,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003786912582760441,
                  "residual_flux": 0.000618024133506504,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 21452.374 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 22047.273,
                  "dA_df": -197.00000000000006,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.7376087131632533,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 345,
                  "max_depth": 0.10632461487052336,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.02294244280516737,
                  "residual_flux": 0.003744206665803315,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 22047.273 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 22059.289,
                  "dA_df": -10.999999999999233,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.08829525952307668,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 262,
                  "max_depth": 0.3446990576436566,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.04918407950260852,
                  "residual_flux": 0.008026841774825712,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 22059.289 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 23348.382,
                  "dA_df": -9.000000000000341,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.05041288944278637,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 400,
                  "max_depth": 0.12018372781097553,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.034322500982287896,
                  "residual_flux": 0.005601432160309385,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 23348.382 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 23379.139,
                  "dA_df": -8.000000000000007,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.2529156823107847,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219 min_mtrans (molecfit model)",
                  "clean_edge": 0.01,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 400,
                  "max_depth": 0.4810202829558673,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.19371605569147093,
                  "residual_flux": 0.03161446028884806,
                  "residual_basis": "NO independent correction covers 23379.139 A for solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219; BOUNDED: own sky absorption x the J arm's measured residual/absorption ratio (RYA-1232 CN budget) 0.1632"
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "K",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "21323.779": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.026,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "21335.026": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 18,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 18,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.046,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "22047.272": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.004,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "22059.289": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.008,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "23348.378": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.306,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "23379.140": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.331,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_k_19452_24846/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "98ae892cd9e15ee30dd6a538d0e499c10c72f1a8044176d9fd098dfa15a58c14",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.02009514285714286,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            6.566857142857141e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001717148159999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0012250000000000002,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.012625916738198,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.1861504041971691,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.1861504041971691
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_c3424dc5ffc7",
        "pk_83afa68ad9f4",
        "pk_83b8e85c0994",
        "pk_e1d2f8403eef",
        "pk_cfdf1a8cf436",
        "pk_c6fd7bfc45ee",
        "pk_edfd5383feca"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.1861504041971691,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_19455_24842_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_19455_24842_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "85a28d5ca0419bb0e25f2b1d1d156b01e28165d9ee3550bf26781fb7ab28c01c",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T14:11:59Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T14:12:16Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.14650485608723987,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.14175733793050313,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-caab8cbc99e0"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.213,
      "sigma_stat": 0.292,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.20693 dex at n_lines=3",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2919999999999998,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.4129503602129435,
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.009050966799187809,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016743999999999995,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0575/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.016743999999999995,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.016743999999999995,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.016743999999999995,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.05749999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01175,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.0235,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.185,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.185,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0799119474319347,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 11403.761,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.1598238948638694,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.811159587773262,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 197,
                  "max_depth": 0.6060034997758728,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.10231182220755865,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219 vs independent correction solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.026637315810643887
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -27.99999999999958,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "11403.766": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.424,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0852639999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            8.192e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00028036153599999983,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001380625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.034225,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0063859193423642935,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.35615136301629424,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.35615136301629424
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.35615136301629424,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "19cb2f3f17c0cedd2c09be68263008d154a446c0de86684c7e19cf8c5a0e3e17",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:36:36Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:48Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.29433404492175197,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.2919999999999998,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-1229a0a156f8"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 5.901,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 2,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0757140378576535,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 74
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.010191999999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0350/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.010191999999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.010191999999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.010191999999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.03499999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0015,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.003,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.04,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -27.99999999999958,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0197395454545454,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4f521738f38ce4cd13274c090d4141db985b6e6778eb952ecc40dad941e03a61",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0057326155287101875,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00010387686399999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.25e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0016,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.09471595637858592,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.09471595637858592
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.09471595637858592,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "a4356b624400b3c9408443c9dc39400071440d1103d40f331b6f7239d5cef5eb",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T15:00:49Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:18Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.08426829491991747,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0757140378576535,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f1c4ef0ec48e"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.196,
      "sigma_stat": 0.279,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.20369 dex at n_lines=3",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2789999999999999,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.3945655839020934,
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.009050966799187809,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.035671999999999995,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.1225/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.035671999999999995,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.035671999999999995,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.035671999999999995,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.12249999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.00925,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.0185,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2235,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2235,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 11403.761,
                  "dA_df": -0.0,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.811159587773262,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 197,
                  "max_depth": 0.6060034997758728,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.10231182220755865,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219 vs independent correction solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.026637315810643887
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -28.00000000000047,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "11403.766": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.424,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.07784099999999995,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            8.192e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0012724915839999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.556249999999999e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.049952250000000004,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.36014129738756695,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.36014129738756695
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.36014129738756695,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "bd39d1fc15fb2066cb40e085b0545e1c1f002ba96cae39d45212daeae1fc42c6",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:38:27Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:52Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.28144187677031995,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.2789999999999999,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-65e9578f5f35"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.215,
      "sigma_stat": 0.292,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.20908 dex at n_lines=3",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2919999999999998,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.4129503602129435,
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.009050966799187809,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.017471999999999994,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0600/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.017471999999999994,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.017471999999999994,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.017471999999999994,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.059999999999999984,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01175,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.0235,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.178,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.178,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0665932895266083,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 11403.761,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.1331865790532166,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.811159587773262,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 197,
                  "max_depth": 0.6060034997758728,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.10231182220755865,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219 vs independent correction solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.026637315810643887
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -27.99999999999958,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": []
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "11403.766": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.424,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "4ffa724552103c0bd7111078db96d1fc9b98816e9095bb7f7caa36af782a08b7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0852639999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            8.192e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0003052707839999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001380625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.031684,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.004434666209974679,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.3498234547510709,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.3498234547510709
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.3498234547510709,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_11161_12976_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "270e9cd03ccd25a179b9a3ccad645bfa0ca98d3d62e058ce86aba8335b1eaac9",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:36:35Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:48Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.29433404492175197,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.2919999999999998,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-448c77475a54"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.123,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0326,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "telluric residual",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0285836340053018,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 96
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0050/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2143111056385086,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.111,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.207,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.008,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -20.999999999999908,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.07031
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008170241329490455,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.04592925,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            6.4e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.21781819039958314,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.21781819039958314
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.21781819039958314,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "7628cbc4e687c0452d43a0b31aaa1f4e62b056c268f7d11ed329bb0e0e99b0d0",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:57:54Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:13Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.046749910512738385,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0285836340053018,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-85aee27b99bb"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.105,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0326,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "telluric residual",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0285836340053018,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 96
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0050/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2143111056385086,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.111,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.207,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.008,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -20.999999999999908,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0179368181818181,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.07031
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008170241329490455,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.04592925,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            6.4e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.21987442795593362,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.21987442795593362
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.21987442795593362,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "412cbe6d257022637dc60f35f3cfb06515ad8abe122a5c68300c0a23a2da0c85",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T15:00:33Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:17Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.046749910512738385,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0285836340053018,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-118aa2ad0c1e"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.108,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0326,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "telluric residual",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0390123610653644,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 96
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0000/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2081273648514294,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.108,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.201,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.082,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.082,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -28.999999999999915,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.07031
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00152196431589436,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.043317000000000015,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.006724000000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.22846298237547014,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.22846298237547014
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.22846298237547014,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "8fbafc773b75526b06383b9ef8f66edc1214243565dce4c7b78c59720344f1f3",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:38:11Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:51Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.05376331756778372,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0390123610653644,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-81eca203f5c6"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "crires_plus",
      "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.122,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0326,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "telluric residual",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|crires_plus|solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0286283413007369,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 96
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0050/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2143111056385086,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.111,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.207,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.008,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -20.999999999999908,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.07031
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "c3c8d0fc983be6ef4151e78c13ffd9e1ec41ada9c0d394eb4fca92eb8c621b2b",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.000819581925631478,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.04592925,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            6.4e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.2178240617141079,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.2178240617141079
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.2178240617141079,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9801_10794_crires_plus_solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "9ca6a2addb6bb9a771591fe49e694dda8ed0f8de5457a7ccacdbc224c62a6897",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:57:52Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:13Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04677725863741354,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0286283413007369,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6637f12ec02e"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.301,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0200520162804131,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 210
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_80126d52e014"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.014,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.028,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.02,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.018054198973412785,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 10746.455,
                  "dA_df": -12.9999999999999,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.018054198973412785,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9983615556730356,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 76,
                  "max_depth": 0.06374371926171407,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003924170989084556,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0013887845364163787
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.06183
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "10746.449": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.059,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01622498073958795,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=1)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.013500000000000068,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.008999999999999897,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.027000000000000135,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.017999999999999794,
              "n_scott_lines": 1,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0004020833569099521,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00019600000000000002,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0004,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00032595410057157927,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0002632499999999999
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0419476721819165,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0419476721819165
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_80126d52e014"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0419476721819165,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "sha256": "ac51d1691cec1b5c2b0620d861facd3d497c7777def6b9dc5deaf2f3852e278d",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:36:14Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:47Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.039564293964507335,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0200520162804131,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03410645100270621,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-18e5094f3c43"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.328,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0200520162804131,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 210
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_80126d52e014"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.014,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.028,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.02,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.018054198973412785,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 10746.455,
                  "dA_df": -12.9999999999999,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.018054198973412785,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9983615556730356,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 76,
                  "max_depth": 0.06374371926171407,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003924170989084556,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0013887845364163787
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.006,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.06183
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "10746.449": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.059,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01622498073958795,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=1)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.013500000000000068,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.008999999999999897,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.027000000000000135,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.017999999999999794,
              "n_scott_lines": 1,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0004020833569099521,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00019600000000000002,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0004,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00032595410057157927,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0002632499999999999
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0515713796740162,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0515713796740162
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_80126d52e014"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0515713796740162,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "5a942097485360ede954297b82511720626211cfb78fd872b0bbf396d9918021",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:37:58Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:50Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.039564293964507335,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0200520162804131,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03410645100270621,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c474eb26f3ae"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.295,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0200520162804131,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 210
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_80126d52e014"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.014,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.028,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.02,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.018054198973412785,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 10746.455,
                  "dA_df": -12.9999999999999,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.018054198973412785,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9983615556730356,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 76,
                  "max_depth": 0.06374371926171407,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003924170989084556,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0013887845364163787
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.006,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.06183
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "10746.449": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.059,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01622498073958795,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=1)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.013500000000000068,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.008999999999999897,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.027000000000000135,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.017999999999999794,
              "n_scott_lines": 1,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0004020833569099521,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00019600000000000002,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0004,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00032595410057157927,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0002632499999999999
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0515713796740162,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0515713796740162
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_80126d52e014"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0515713796740162,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "85902f0963dd8d43d80442159ffca5547c8690676fcf4b5c1ffa3905f6ffcbb1",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:37:59Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:51Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.039564293964507335,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0200520162804131,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03410645100270621,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bb8baa1178c8"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.266,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.177951520023391,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 210
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_80126d52e014"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.018927999999999993,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0650/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.018927999999999993,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.018927999999999993,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.018927999999999993,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.06499999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.011,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.022,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.017,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.017,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.019442983509829627,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 10746.455,
                  "dA_df": -14.000000000000234,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.019442983509829627,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9983615556730356,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 76,
                  "max_depth": 0.06374371926171407,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003924170989084556,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0013887845364163787
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.06183
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "10746.449": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.059,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01622498073958795,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=1)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.013500000000000068,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.008999999999999897,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.027000000000000135,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.017999999999999794,
              "n_scott_lines": 1,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.03166674347863533,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00035826918399999973,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00012099999999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00028900000000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0003780296077635068,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0002632499999999999
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.1823187655464978,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.1823187655464978
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_80126d52e014"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.1823187655464978,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "95f3c092c788875b199de7ccffa16b322d64645e54893323d2b33316e99b2606",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:37:53Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:50Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.18119048948174774,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.177951520023391,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03410645100270621,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bf2a2938353f"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.303,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0200933731264724,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 210
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0128,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_80126d52e014"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.014,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.028,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.019,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.019,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016665414436997174,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 10746.455,
                  "dA_df": -12.000000000000455,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.016665414436997174,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9983615556730356,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 76,
                  "max_depth": 0.06374371926171407,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.003924170989084556,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0013887845364163787
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                1.06183
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "10746.449": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.059,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01622498073958795,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=1)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "5d45bc31f393441389a89e03e61921b9a337e4a9e4fe4ee309cfb3eed233ef0f",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.013500000000000068,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.008999999999999897,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.027000000000000135,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.017999999999999794,
              "n_scott_lines": 1,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0004037436435996432,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00016384,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00019600000000000002,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.000361,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00027773603835687383,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0002632499999999999
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.04091514910099335,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.04091514910099335
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_80126d52e014"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.04091514910099335,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "c478ea55e4f912707d41f8b8a8c2d434202a0cd634f64cbd13614303427cd3bf",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:36:10Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:47Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.03958527053841672,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0200933731264724,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03410645100270621,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-dc40cd57490f"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.252,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1469,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 3,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.17379 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.14690284015104826,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "n_components": 3,
              "raw_sigma": 0.25444318291778484,
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.00739008344562721,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b",
                "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.007279999999999997,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 3 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.007279999999999997,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.007279999999999997,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.007279999999999997,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.02499999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0255,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.051,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.039,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.039,
              "n_paired": 3,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.051101464647190904,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -16.000000000000014,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 11403.761,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.15330439394157272,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.811159587773262,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 197,
                  "max_depth": 0.6060034997758728,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.10231182220755865,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.025550732323594484
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -27.000000000000135,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99726,
                0.99881,
                1.05725
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "11403.766": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.424,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.021580444444444437,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            5.4613333333333334e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            5.2998399999999963e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0006502499999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.001521,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.002611359689088102,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.16413164188195364,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.16413164188195364
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b",
        "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.16413164188195364,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "84cb1112a4ecb95c95bb8aba721997d52c388390813bf94e65491dd90c9a0ad4",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:36:12Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:47Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.15148918919990442,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.14690284015104826,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bdcd99128c04"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.067,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1669,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 2,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.16690 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1669013636363634,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.23603417203310886,
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.009050966799187809,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b",
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0075/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.007499999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04499513862630051,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.0265,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.043,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0055,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0055,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -16.000000000000014,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -27.000000000000135,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.018838181818181747,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99726,
                1.05725
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "531124595c45c160afa3b89ed8bd748895971712bb907158ced2986fd120df5d",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.027856065183677607,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            8.192e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            4.769855999999997e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0020245625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.0249999999999997e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.17710476430541786,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.17710476430541786
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b",
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.17710476430541786,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "204f256c466e8270262593b54d12e3b51acc2170338de9f2e04ae5fa59c9bc15",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T15:00:12Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:15Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.17095202597125783,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.1669013636363634,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bd12d76eaf22"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.232,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1415,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 3,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.15571 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.141452386963875,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "n_components": 3,
              "raw_sigma": 0.245002721073325,
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.00739008344562721,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b",
                "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 3 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0250/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.014999999999999996,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0165,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.033,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.066,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.066,
              "n_paired": 3,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03406764309812223,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -14.99999999999968,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 11403.761,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.10220292929436668,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.811159587773262,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 197,
                  "max_depth": 0.6060034997758728,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.10231182220755865,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.025550732323594484
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -21.000000000000796,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99726,
                0.99881,
                1.05725
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "11403.766": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.424,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.020008777777777834,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            5.4613333333333334e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            1.9079423999999988e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00027225000000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0043560000000000005,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.001160604306261035,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.16229557862545796,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.16229557862545796
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b",
        "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.16229557862545796,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "d85e58698394ed4706deede66bab6246e86e9befb9a8869f47dbc455341cdd4b",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:37:49Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:49Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.14620980739258851,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.141452386963875,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c0ce41acfee8"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "NIR",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.251,
      "sigma_stat": 0.147,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 3,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.17110 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|NIR|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.14697429858463174,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "n_components": 3,
              "raw_sigma": 0.2545669525553807,
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.00739008344562721,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_580db05f6e0b",
                "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
                "pk_741bd7667951"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.010191999999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 3 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.010191999999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.010191999999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.010191999999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.03499999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0255,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.051,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.039,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.039,
              "n_paired": 3,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04258455387265656,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 9961.256,
                  "dA_df": -16.000000000000014,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008929097999537,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.010144902096033914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 11403.761,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.1277536616179697,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.811159587773262,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 197,
                  "max_depth": 0.6060034997758728,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.10231182220755865,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.025550732323594484
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 12319.98,
                  "dA_df": -27.000000000000135,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.0027008727957454804,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9936474066737022,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00258720204896834,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "NIR",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99726,
                0.99881,
                1.05725
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "11403.766": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.424,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "12319.980": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 9,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 9,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.075,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_ir_9200_13000/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "25cd0360c1b526c17c3ac5523c3f66e660850292f37c4733dd293dace947460c",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.021601444444444482,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            5.4613333333333334e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00010387686399999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0006502499999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.001521,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0018134442285331891,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.16190478334598707,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.16190478334598707
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_580db05f6e0b",
        "pk_56e7e9a48dc1",
        "pk_741bd7667951"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.16190478334598707,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_9203_12976_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "d11fbf0116cfdd9e7056ef7e0b2ad2e40799ce5ffc32df44589b8bea8de0754a",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:36:08Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:46Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.1515584852274675,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.14697429858463174,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-186caf770fd6"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.278,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0361,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03614 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03613862199918528,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.07227724399837056,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943557,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0325/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.040650953248355694,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.007,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0405,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0005,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0005,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -6.999999999999673,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.9934,
                1.0004
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0013059999999999981,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162500000000006,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0016525000000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.5e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0606057541492555,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0606057541492555
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0606057541492555,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "sha256": "d68b544b10283803c97fc3ee0c73fc2c662a686782ae9f3ee58daa71b3fe0bc6",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-02T16:08:50Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-02T16:09:18Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.05231216397741543,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.03613862199918528,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-65aef47bc520"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.264,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0368,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03677 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03677266874550528,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.07354533749101055,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943557,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0325/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.040650953248355694,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.007,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0405,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0005,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0005,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -7.000000000000561,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.04,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.9934,
                1.0004
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0013522291666666607,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162500000000006,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0016525000000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.5e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.06796533383031869,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.06796533383031869
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.06796533383031869,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "d893fbe673fe87013b73fc3eb1c362483256b35f85f80cea7ec220fe8bf5dc61",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-02T16:08:57Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-02T16:09:19Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.052752172151169875,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.03677266874550528,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.226,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0389,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03893 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.038928352991960194,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.07785670598392039,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943557,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0325/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.040650953248355694,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.007,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0405,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0005,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0005,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -6.999999999998785,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.04,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.9934,
                1.0004
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0015154166666666562,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162500000000006,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0016525000000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.5e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.06915543436828851,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.06915543436828851
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.06915543436828851,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "d2b7147c70d50ae78d0b14b32d8d8276b4a6f1ad266501fe62958a4321a7234b",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-02T16:09:04Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-02T16:09:21Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.0542768750635725,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.038928352991960194,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-d70898a6d4f2"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.263,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0379,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03790 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03789761426088281,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.07579522852176562,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943557,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0275/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.014999999999999996,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03528809997718778,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.009,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.035,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0085,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0085,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": 1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -11.999999999999567,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": 126.99999999999977,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": 2.9999999999992255,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.9934,
                1.0004
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0014362291666666683,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162500000000006,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            1.9079423999999988e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00124525,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            7.225000000000001e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.059033855461647355,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.059033855461647355
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.059033855461647355,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "9fe9efcd996112f2c6942c85edf64c945ea231021514b0558da9aacff15a2991",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-02T16:07:14Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-02T16:09:14Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.05354242865865042,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.03789761426088281,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9439cb57fb7e"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.282,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0362,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03625 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03624770107652811,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.07249540215305622,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943557,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0300/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.002499999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04015283302582771,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.007,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.04,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -7.000000000000561,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.9934,
                1.0004
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.001313895833333337,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162500000000006,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            5.299839999999997e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0016122500000000002,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.06032299161458539,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.06032299161458539
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.06032299161458539,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "f13cc9c5589c55a7bcb8c32137143d23a97a19e2ae41693d8939e5eada1092fd",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-02T16:05:17Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-02T16:09:13Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.05238757804416367,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.03624770107652811,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-5919b5d71e97"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.228,
      "sigma_stat": 0.013,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01300 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.012999999999999899,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.018384776310850094,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0200/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.020402205763103164,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.012,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.0195,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2905,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2905,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.91963,
                1.06412
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00016899999999999736,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00041624999999999995,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.08439024999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.29238193168525306,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.29238193168525306
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.29238193168525306,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "269f75dd5ffa4e223ee455925d2411c406970c2084c7f2ba346a0345195b129a",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:56:18Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:10Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.03921135039755707,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.012999999999999899,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-ab243f5f7fb7"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.239,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0112,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01120 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.011200000000000099,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.015839191898578804,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0200/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.020402205763103164,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.012,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.0195,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2905,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2905,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0694072727272727,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1388145454545454,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.91963,
                1.06412
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00012544000000000221,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00041624999999999995,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.08439024999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.004817369507438014,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.3004346908787965,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.3004346908787965
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.3004346908787965,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "ceb10cd9ddd147790390497d9fbfe8e7ad14abe65621d042b0dec2756a43c2b2",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:57:26Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:04Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07356180739648814,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.011200000000000099,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.07270419181476413,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-cd4f141ff187"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.102,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (cited NIST class)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0179348530797427,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 124
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0043,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0200/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02524381112272868,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.007,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.025,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.158,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.158,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0694072727272727,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1388145454545454,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.91963
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0003216589549919562,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            1.849e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0006372500000000002,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.024964,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.004817369507438014,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.17680842015704448,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.17680842015704448
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.17680842015704448,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "5090e652f31d52019d3058399565aa9da223c3e22c295299fc00cab0be9d5a01",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:57:27Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:04Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07488363280737635,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0179348530797427,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.07270419181476413,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-77cd03c01180"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.218,
      "sigma_stat": 0.013,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01300 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.012999999999999899,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.018384776310850094,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.011647999999999997,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0400/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.011647999999999997,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.011647999999999997,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.011647999999999997,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.03999999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02240675121475668,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0085,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.022,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.3685,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.3685,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -6.999999999999673,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": 9.999999999999787,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.91963,
                1.06412
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00016899999999999736,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00013567590399999992,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005020625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.13579225,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.37023879240835905,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.37023879240835905
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.37023879240835905,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "8028fa86eafc8a08be138b603bf3399a985ea322a26120e428368a75c3e5e43e",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:02:52Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:05:09Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.03921135039755707,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.012999999999999899,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-252fafda80c1"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.243,
      "sigma_stat": 0.014,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01400 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01399999999999979,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.019798989873223035,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0175/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.017499999999999995,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02000156243896961,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0125,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.019,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2405,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2405,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -2.000000000000668,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.91963,
                1.06412
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00019599999999999414,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.596921599999999e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0004000625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.057840249999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.24277573337547556,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.24277573337547556
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.24277573337547556,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "f39635618e7304e8f4cdd2bb9f7a9fdd8c8247adc823f81bc2933c21ae91e98c",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:55:55Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:10Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.039554140112003394,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.01399999999999979,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f7b85afbd89a"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.283,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0719,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.07191 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.07191221973307999,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.1902618496403613,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.99283,
                0.9934,
                0.99346,
                1.0004,
                1.07876
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0051713673469387786,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.07739363582556595,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.07739363582556595
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.07739363582556595,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "bcb4ec69fedc8f7e1e31010550919e890f2cb0f47f9a619bd7200e79d79cb1ce",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:51Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:09Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.08125226056509924,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.07191221973307999,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4c88219f1ea2"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.264,
      "sigma_stat": 0.082,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 6,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.08197 dex at n_lines=6",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08196831366109987,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 6,
              "n_components": 6,
              "raw_sigma": 0.20078054354609837,
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.019177566428798837,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.052500000000000005,
              "n_lines": 6,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.9934,
                0.99346,
                1.0004,
                1.07876
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.006718804444444452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00036777905413099216,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.09228838496027247,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.09228838496027247
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.09228838496027247,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "2c15b4bb43a04f9b0ae1497390c5de0bfe06fe28e7b010dac894c4d455abaee6",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:51Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:10Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.09027384418780698,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.08196831366109987,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-034d202da814"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.226,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0634,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.06340 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.06340128368738253,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.16774402943907038,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0536259090909091,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.99283,
                0.9934,
                0.99346,
                1.0004,
                1.07876
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.004019722773207958,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.07575044747438463,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.07575044747438463
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.07575044747438463,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "68869cf20412afb0212c0e5ec61e0a716394d2edb086bee83350f5ed0a4c6860",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:51Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:11Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07382604738984717,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.06340128368738253,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-1a483ec17b8d"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.265,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0602,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.06020 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.060200232783693436,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.15927484481385046,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.99283,
                0.9934,
                0.99346,
                1.0004,
                1.07876
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.003624068027210878,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.06665189829684093,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.06665189829684093
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.06665189829684093,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "8983f724d9f1b56d801d17a3f7205996ad7aefd49d771a9a40e6fc2fcb9a57fd",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:51Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:07Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07109592482843781,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.060200232783693436,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a3583bba6864"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "harps",
      "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.287,
      "sigma_stat": 0.072,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.07196 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|harps|solar_harps_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.07195515421209986,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.19037544359451802,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.93653,
                0.99255,
                0.99283,
                0.9934,
                0.99346,
                1.0004,
                1.07876
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.005177544217687072,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0774335310898878,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0774335310898878
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0774335310898878,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6908_harps_solar_harps_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "57682e1fba7cb7571e33bd3d99c259b612d49e45addb2da4461ad649de636ff7",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:51Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:06Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.08129026213321663,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.07195515421209986,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-abce6000c004"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.3,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0285,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02849 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02849086110784767,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.05698172221569534,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0300/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03796379854545643,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.017,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.037,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98685,
                0.99043,
                0.99588,
                0.99643
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.000811729166666667,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0014412499999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.054472806084014704,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.054472806084014704
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.054472806084014704,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "sha256": "6ba261b68ebfffbee23a52428e96e407be4e88ec0eac12d1940ac35d1fa6a4e5",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:55:00Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:08Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.0473528422237427,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02849086110784767,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b06ed066892d"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.287,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0287,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02871 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.028714108030722437,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.057428216061444874,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0300/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03796379854545643,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.017,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.037,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.04,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98685,
                0.99043,
                0.99588,
                0.99643
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008244999999999987,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0014412499999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.06229010704758823,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.06229010704758823
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.06229010704758823,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "0b724699b9c946798637afd7cf1d5424316ea56491f10a2a63ff1575a90859be",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:33:29Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:35Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.047487498354830196,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.028714108030722437,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-620b8337a6f5"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.248,
      "sigma_stat": 0.03,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02995 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.029953783845562274,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.05990756769112455,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0300/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03796379854545643,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.017,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.037,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.04,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98685,
                0.99043,
                0.99588,
                0.99643
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008972291666666675,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0014412499999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0628711905618676,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0628711905618676
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0628711905618676,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "7b81081217218bdf10c54cb326f4eb64cefa5532ca67dd635b500529f4556b81",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:33:30Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:35Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04824719335533073,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.029953783845562274,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.284,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0296,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02955 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02955362357929513,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.05910724715859026,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0400/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.007499999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.015532224567009067,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.017,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.013,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.003,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.003,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -12.9999999999999,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -5.000000000000782,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": 8.000000000000007,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98685,
                0.99043,
                0.99588,
                0.99643
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008734166666666691,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            4.769855999999997e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00024125,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            9e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.04290249436415873,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.04290249436415873
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.04290249436415873,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "d4bea92278ef6811cf9cbdf6fa76ef36102b94c57c0ea341d91ade96638f6cdd",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:33:11Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:33Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04799978298562058,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02955362357929513,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b90c5f56677b"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.305,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0285,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02854 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02853652630109935,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.0570730526021987,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0350/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.007499999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03693321675673539,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0165,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.036,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -2.9999999999992255,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98685,
                0.99043,
                0.99588,
                0.99643
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.000814333333333335,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            4.769855999999997e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0013640624999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.05380848622042193,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.05380848622042193
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.05380848622042193,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "c8f1d291b0bf35fb472811aa97964b5681587e66e231c46042b93e4f8380130a",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:54:38Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:07Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.047380331714049206,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02853652630109935,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c00f6af0b401"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.25,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — measured random RMS 0.00650 dex sits below one 0.01 dex synthesis tread, so the engine cannot resolve it",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.006499999999999949,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.009192388155425047,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0175/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.017499999999999995,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04760317741495834,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0245,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.046,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.3205,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.3205,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95037,
                1.01839
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            4.224999999999934e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.596921599999999e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0022660625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.10272025,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.32485736364749374,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.32485736364749374
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.32485736364749374,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "57416ef33d7013a2bc058502192ec4bd4508b6cf6edfb6a1141b46289d2d9acf",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:54:59Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:08Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.03756035143605556,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.006499999999999949,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-3549f0317ecb"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.26,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — measured random RMS 0.00830 dex sits below one 0.01 dex synthesis tread, so the engine cannot resolve it",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.00829999999999975,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.011737972567696337,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0175/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.017499999999999995,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04760317741495834,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0245,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.046,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.3205,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.3205,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0694072727272727,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1388145454545454,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95037,
                1.01839
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            6.888999999999585e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.596921599999999e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0022660625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.10272025,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.004817369507438014,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.332229312709517,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.332229312709517
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.332229312709517,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "da3eec9c16d77fec16d320460ab9478a26252f2779815c27429c4d59c4d3bdde",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:54:51Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:00:56Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07317642726614912,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.00829999999999975,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.07270419181476413,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-841d473766d8"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.104,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (cited NIST class)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0171547752262133,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 1124
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0043,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0200/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04279310692155922,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.059,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.031,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.161,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.161,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0694072727272727,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1388145454545454,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95037
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00029428631306190154,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            1.849e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0018312499999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.025921000000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.004817369507438014,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.18271520132846067,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.18271520132846067
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.18271520132846067,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "173da918ff7c52661bf38c19e32e796d99d92cc10a8ca22aff7322d80a5bc200",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:54:52Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:00:56Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07470064136605467,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0171547752262133,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.07270419181476413,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b72a4b06a2c1"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.236,
      "sigma_stat": 0.015,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01500 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.015000000000000123,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.0212132034355966,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.044986803620617466,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0295,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.0425,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.3925,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.3925,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95037,
                1.01839
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00022500000000000368,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.002023812500000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.15405625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.39596883367760144,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.39596883367760144
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.39596883367760144,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "3fa28f5575993427e39b6f879723878159375d91ce76468b424938835aaf8c1d",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:01:20Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:05:06Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.03991904307470315,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.015000000000000123,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b1a83c053f0b"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.263,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — measured random RMS 0.00600 dex sits below one 0.01 dex synthesis tread, so the engine cannot resolve it",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.006000000000000227,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.008485281374238892,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0200/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04657252408878007,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.024,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.045,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2545,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2545,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -2.000000000000668,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95037,
                1.01839
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            3.600000000000273e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.002169,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.06477025,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.2597824935903111,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.2597824935903111
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.2597824935903111,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "823b956ede20f5628b1a1dc000a4f64aafbff040d01bb84f8c55c4cc080817db",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:54:36Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:07Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.037477059649871206,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.006000000000000227,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-58dd461d3e5a"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.29,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0253,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02525 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.025252870787163983,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06681281599328381,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98509,
                0.98685,
                0.99042,
                0.99588,
                0.99602,
                0.99643,
                1.00869
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0006377074829932001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0381590749672309,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0381590749672309
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0381590749672309,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "448658bbc71fa60ba7d16a85ed5b509624d38ae3397fe4e623d5ecea81c245cb",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:49Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:31:55Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04547823636634563,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.025252870787163983,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-5a5ee22946b5"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.287,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0328,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 6,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03278 dex at n_lines=6",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03278161747755058,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 6,
              "n_components": 6,
              "raw_sigma": 0.0802982357631019,
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.019177566428798837,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.052500000000000005,
              "n_lines": 6,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98685,
                0.99042,
                0.99588,
                0.99602,
                0.99643,
                1.00869
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0010746344444444497,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00036777905413099216,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.05360014924023481,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.05360014924023481
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.05360014924023481,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "60c7dfb7eafb6ea3c4504a9e0a432cd1bff7dd91717550e6fe3b26882ba928a5",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:49Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:31:57Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.05005194246424859,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.03278161747755058,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-be7b30000a66"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.243,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0257,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02573 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.025727616425248647,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06806887488766851,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0536259090909091,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98509,
                0.98685,
                0.99042,
                0.99588,
                0.99602,
                0.99643,
                1.00869
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.000661910246924724,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.04878850034881449,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.04878850034881449
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.04878850034881449,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "e27601ba6d1678ec98f33933f9133ae163a229420b7213b2babeb5c268d6cd0f",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:49Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:31:58Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04574355415711296,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.025727616425248647,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-23bfd23782d9"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.275,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0252,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02522 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02521715213708242,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06671831332800106,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98509,
                0.98685,
                0.99042,
                0.99588,
                0.99602,
                0.99643,
                1.00869
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0006359047619047605,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.03813544651982337,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.03813544651982337
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.03813544651982337,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "34b47f9422192ad472132f3ff0e1cee7188cb5d055cc39fa2221991f01fa4c8b",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:49Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:31:54Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.045458412443735455,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02521715213708242,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-17cc53288fb1"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.295,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0253,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02527 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0252684902326882,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06685414116175761,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98509,
                0.98685,
                0.99042,
                0.99588,
                0.99602,
                0.99643,
                1.00869
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.000638496598639459,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.03816941338298254,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.03816941338298254
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.03816941338298254,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "62451ed9fe01345663464019ac267dad8671305100db5b8b5169d45b9ee94a33",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:49Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:31:52Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04548691128928695,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0252684902326882,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-36b16e0d3bcd"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.304,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0286,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02862 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02862108779670443,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.05724217559340886,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0375/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.036104881941366324,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0055,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.036,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0005,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0005,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -5.999999999999339,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99183,
                0.99331,
                0.99867,
                0.99989
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008191666666666634,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0013035625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.5e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.053325851241838286,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.053325851241838286
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.053325851241838286,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_products.csv",
        "sha256": "7bbf7f2e4d48696498e2f9dde314d76768c469e07b2cf966b4519af78ab540f0",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:55:34Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:09Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.047431309982612385,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02862108779670443,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bf622c820458"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.291,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0288,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02882 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.028819481258343205,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.05763896251668641,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0375/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.036104881941366324,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0055,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.036,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0005,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0005,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -5.999999999999339,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.04,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99183,
                0.99331,
                0.99867,
                0.99989
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008305624999999953,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0013035625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.5e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.061278399489542786,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.061278399489542786
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.061278399489542786,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "7c7afd9ff53c5b7b9201c5de9f99be9273f542e9e10298bf1f0493ef83b3982d",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:34:25Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:38Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.047551288100323816,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.028819481258343205,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.252,
      "sigma_stat": 0.03,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03000 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02999583304394125,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.0599916660878825,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0375/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0029119999999999992,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.009999999999999997,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.036104881941366324,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0055,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.036,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0005,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0005,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -5.999999999999339,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.04,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99183,
                0.99331,
                0.99867,
                0.99989
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008997499999999978,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.479743999999995e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0013035625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.5e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.06184035692005666,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.06184035692005666
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.06184035692005666,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "ba168f6954daf766df30da18da6c479ae5d4db0bd7d646ffd8d9d527a9aba24d",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:34:26Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:38Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04827331043133462,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02999583304394125,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-fd002196b613"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.278,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0307,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03070 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.030703894975502053,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.061407789951004106,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0275/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.002499999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03863693181400407,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0065,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0385,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0015,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0015,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": 1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": 1.000000000000334,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -14.000000000000234,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -14.000000000000234,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99183,
                0.99331,
                0.99867,
                0.99989
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0009427291666666602,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            5.299839999999997e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0014928125,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.25e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.05612939649298451,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.05612939649298451
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.05612939649298451,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "1b22219ca98444414f0a3316feb86b44ab5912d7fd52dffc1dc217612eeeb261",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:34:08Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:36Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.048716441440920764,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.030703894975502053,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0276917cf012"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "ALL",
      "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.309,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0288,
      "sigma_syst": 0.027,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02876 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|ALL|SET-NA_AGSS21|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-all",
          "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02876485123665097,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.05752970247330194,
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.013476831971943553,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0375/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.007499999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03558791929854849,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.005,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0355,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0005,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0005,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 4751.822,
                  "dA_df": -5.000000000000782,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9971590506278416,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.03142205382959096,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5148.838,
                  "dA_df": -6.000000000000227,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0028822229953838,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04464641002995262,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6154.225,
                  "dA_df": -3.9999999999995595,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0008784039266285,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.00935278338400114,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 6160.747,
                  "dA_df": -3.0000000000001137,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0009961672516061,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.02144246726724819,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99183,
                0.99331,
                0.99867,
                0.99989
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "a2efedbdee99c7b0b8cc538e328ee740fcf9d5b40ffc75e7c7f567b58fd9c257",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0008274166666666609,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00018162499999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            4.769855999999997e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0012664999999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.5e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.05302003416319781,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.05302003416319781
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Reference Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.05302003416319781,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_SET-NA_AGSS21_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "a748ccef52d2350e0acac997b2b524fbe1491d61e2aee6f6314d1a5f244b1b4d",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:55:15Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:09Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.047518198268312564,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02876485123665097,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6d05db230769"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.221,
      "sigma_stat": 0.013,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01300 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.012999999999999899,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.018384776310850094,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0175/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.017499999999999995,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.031679054594479304,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.0255,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.029,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2685,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2685,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -0.9999999999994458,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.94058,
                1.11853
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00016899999999999736,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.596921599999999e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0010035625000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.07209225000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.27160367581459577,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.27160367581459577
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.27160367581459577,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "61f0a5c4c7e524add5c3c069f45a2649cc310388bd72c68ca7b19e451e493940",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:55:33Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:09Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.03921135039755707,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.012999999999999899,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-dd0066591b38"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.232,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0112,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01120 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.011200000000000099,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.015839191898578804,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0175/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.005095999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.017499999999999995,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.031679054594479304,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.0255,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.029,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2685,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2685,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -0.9999999999994458,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0694072727272727,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1388145454545454,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.94058,
                1.11853
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00012544000000000221,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.596921599999999e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0010035625000000003,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.07209225000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.004817369507438014,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.2802541100919628,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.2802541100919628
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.2802541100919628,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "d4ab49cf6d6961a65975c805113780e7ef23efa0318dd05081a835356947fc3c",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:56:01Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:00Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07356180739648814,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.011200000000000099,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.07270419181476413,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-eb26cb8b60bb"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.095,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 1,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (cited NIST class)",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — UNMEASURED: line-to-line scatter at n_lines=1; the floor STANDS IN for a scatter that was never determined, it is not a measurement of one",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0132008210366288,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: one line -> statistical error from the goodness of the profile fit; chi2-curvature sigma of this line, rescaled to red_chi2 = 1",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "profile_likelihood",
              "likelihood": "synthesis chi2 over the fit window, curvature at the best abundance",
              "correlation_treatment": "red_chi2 rescaling absorbs pixel correlation and model inadequacy; the worse-constrained side is taken",
              "n_pixels": 197
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0043,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                1.0
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 1 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0200/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0058239999999999984,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.019999999999999993,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.039195025194532024,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.039,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.034,
              "n_paired": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.158,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.158,
              "n_paired": 1,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0694072727272727,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1388145454545454,
              "n_lines": 1,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.94058
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "74822b14f897dddebe3a200dc8abb2743c11e6cf0752acf8bf3f3e147fb18859",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00017426167604110148,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            1.849e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            3.391897599999998e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00153625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.024964,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.004817369507438014,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.1789212680468119,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.1789212680468119
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.1789212680468119,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "c2e870ab6a6a67ce8df0b25cf49ab057cfc4a02b8598a222963ab220d32e54c1",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:56:02Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:00Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07389290347170774,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0132008210366288,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.07270419181476413,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6f4bd45a4765"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.21,
      "sigma_stat": 0.01,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "quantiser-floor 0.01 dex (RYA-771) — measured random RMS 0.00550 dex sits below one 0.01 dex synthesis tread, so the engine cannot resolve it",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0055000000000000595,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.007778174593052108,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0025/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0007279999999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.002499999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04026474885057648,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.034,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.0365,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.317,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.317,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": 1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -0.0,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.94058,
                1.11853
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            3.0250000000000654e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            5.299839999999997e-07,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00162125,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.10048900000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.3203417003513592,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.3203417003513592
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.3203417003513592,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "ba1874277f447776796e18fdc183df27f2958f08e8fe74aeb4191d59196a4f39",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:02:01Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:05:07Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.03740026737872341,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.0055000000000000595,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a5cee5792af3"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.235,
      "sigma_stat": 0.014,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0043,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.01400 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01399999999999979,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.019798989873223035,
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0030405591591021546,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_70ba90e66612",
                "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0043,
                0.0043
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6568,T6567)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy AA; TP ref T6617,T6567)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  1.849e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  1.849e-05
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0150/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.014999999999999996,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03132491021535417,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": -0.026,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": -0.0285,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.208,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.208,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.62,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5889.951,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9932647875483442,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.1374837051851343,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 5895.924,
                  "dA_df": -2.000000000000668,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9977445153141311,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06542054047804502,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.94058,
                1.11853
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "51b786a8c3f895a6cddb9a46662604d82e95f36c500c3887c962be3b4f91d6bb",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00019599999999999414,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            9.245000000000002e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            1.9079423999999988e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00098125,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.043264,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.21198609488360312,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.21198609488360312
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_70ba90e66612",
        "pk_0569c6d55ac7"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.21198609488360312,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "30eb8da3e0a95cfd3a369ce903fa041c122f6ec7377d42a5a7a296b62af947c9",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T08:55:13Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T08:58:08Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.039554140112003394,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.01399999999999979,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-93bab5e00805"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.294,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0235,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (cited NIST class)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02354 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02354211741787486,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06228658802357895,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98765,
                0.99183,
                0.9933,
                0.99748,
                0.99867,
                0.99989,
                1.00651
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0005542312925170069,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.0370491405012121,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.0370491405012121
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.0370491405012121,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "9e8f7ddf02ece07078045c1bc7fc826409f14dc4c98b94df5e8ac399a4514bf4",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:50Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:02Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04455102459559161,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02354211741787486,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-eeac09562b71"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 3D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.291,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0318,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 6,
      "n_excluded": 1,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.03178 dex at n_lines=6",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A-3DNLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03177792735007537,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 6,
              "n_components": 6,
              "raw_sigma": 0.07783970709091863,
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.019177566428798837,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666,
                0.16666666666666666
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.052500000000000005,
              "n_lines": 6,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.99183,
                0.9933,
                0.99748,
                0.99867,
                0.99989,
                1.00651
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "028d6c791282c67593599ae6a754d830673f9cc060e8d36f966d92c4121e1483",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0010098366666666681,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00036777905413099216,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.05299224679892015,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.05299224679892015
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.05299224679892015,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A-3DNLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "a609221744e38bc2b6d3c47c32a94b0607cc8d016ada853a8fc81aef7559ba11",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:50Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:03Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04940039642216113,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.03177792735007537,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f8e30b062164"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.247,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0257,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02570 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.025698592785737256,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06799208555537938,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0536259090909091,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98765,
                0.99183,
                0.9933,
                0.99748,
                0.99867,
                0.99989,
                1.00651
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.000660417671167147,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.04877320156119234,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.04877320156119234
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.04877320156119234,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "99dbec54490eaefb06167770aa277d580ca47203e16b2586644a97b610452413",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:50Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:04Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04572723664477386,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.025698592785737256,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6f7a1bf44b76"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.266,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0249,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02494 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.024939382292182836,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06598340339668378,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98765,
                0.99183,
                0.9933,
                0.99748,
                0.99867,
                0.99989,
                1.00651
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0006219727891156429,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.03795234259538126,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.03795234259538126
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.03795234259538126,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "99ba1c28324919f6c2f6ea8fdcb0012e8baab1290fa033888b919858bf0b042b",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:50Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:32:00Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04530491462430588,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.024939382292182836,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-8260a258557d"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "VIS",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.298,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0235,
      "sigma_syst": 0.0242,
      "n_lines": 7,
      "n_excluded": 18,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (cited NIST class)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02355 dex at n_lines=7",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|VIS|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02354702921886351,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 7,
              "n_components": 7,
              "raw_sigma": 0.06229958342748436,
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016965995973167777,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NA_AGSS21: fully_correlated (scale 0.0000 dex; Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 (A&A 653, A141) Table A.1); NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fec47b945d92",
                "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
                "pk_37121ddc8791",
                "pk_4eef882e0f61",
                "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
                "pk_0bd9252c4726",
                "pk_b89849d188b8"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.07188200730612536,
                0.0128,
                0.0128
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285,
                0.14285714285714285
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A; sigma from NIST class C+ via gf_grades.nist_sigma_dex (row names classes ['A', 'C+']; the worse is charged)",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A",
                "NIST ASD v5.11 grade A"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00171396,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00086436,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0051670229743578594,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00016384
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "VIS",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98765,
                0.99183,
                0.9933,
                0.99748,
                0.99867,
                0.99989,
                1.00651
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "xi_minus",
                "xi_plus"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "q80",
                "q97",
                "contref"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "core"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "not in the Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1 budget (stat, atmosphere, half the 3D effect, NLTE); RYA-1315 runs only those legs",
            "evidence": {
              "asplund_budget": true,
              "legs_not_run": [
                "cscale"
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.02303394234602497,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (pool lines, n=4)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "87714646eeb01023de9341d56ecdbdbcbd7fe75e90f84114c7099dab007465c7",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.020750000000000157,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009999999999999787,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.041500000000000314,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019999999999999574,
              "n_scott_lines": 4,
              "basis": "pool lines",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0005544625850340119,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0002878450193615452,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0005305625000000024
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.03705226179864813,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.03705226179864813
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fec47b945d92",
        "pk_dc12fe2a0cbc",
        "pk_37121ddc8791",
        "pk_4eef882e0f61",
        "pk_9730f46aa0ba",
        "pk_0bd9252c4726",
        "pk_b89849d188b8"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.03705226179864813,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Sirius",
        "path": "/home/damienabraxas/scratch/rya1315/gerber_wt/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_4200_6910_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "afd13a347d6f78f64372c57f0ee45884f2289b8bd52b31441165f85e76b98f1a",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-11-04T01:31:50Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-11-04T01:31:59Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04455362033588307,
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.02354702921886351,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.037822777528891266,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "publication_id": "Na-products-aac4173b0ef6"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.689,
      "sigma_stat": 0.148,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.14800 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1479999999999997,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.20930360723121763,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08080799999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.2775/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.08080799999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.08080799999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.08080799999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.2774999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0475,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0475,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.90529,
                0.91405
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.021903999999999906,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.006529932863999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00225625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.17724492338005032,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.17724492338005032
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.17724492338005032,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "923c1f19a9aaa285c6f5f7c1f7ed6654cb9c6b01da61528cc491c179bd34b78a",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:32:13Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:38Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.15255336771110597,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.1479999999999997,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4d5f9acb10d8"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.574,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1471,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.14715 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.14714999999999942,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.20810152570320015,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08080799999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.2775/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.08080799999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.08080799999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.08080799999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.2774999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0475,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0475,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0573552272727273,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1147104545454546,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.90529,
                0.91405
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.02165312249999983,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.006529932863999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00225625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0032896220955062018,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.1856192540107465,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.1856192540107465
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.1856192540107465,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "dd9d9863730a9847345b54ddfb89b9fd3be0141adc259a0fee75e8e9b023f035",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:53:31Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:00:52Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.15940914213277116,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.14714999999999942,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.061303769015503475,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0c24e0ee234b"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.671,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1365,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.13650 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.13649999999999984,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.19304015126392726,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.07935199999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.2725/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.07935199999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.07935199999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.07935199999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.2724999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0375,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.0375,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.90529,
                0.91405
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.018632249999999958,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.006296739903999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00140625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.16450173222188258,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.16450173222188258
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.16450173222188258,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "72fa12bbdb4f2b345f9bf03cd6403f8f5632f3f7092d4b4bb09f7f2487903c0b",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:32:21Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:31Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.14142411392686877,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.13649999999999984,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9e68e7906843"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.713,
      "sigma_stat": 0.14,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.14000 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.13999999999999968,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.19798989873223286,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08153599999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.2800/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.08153599999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.08153599999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.08153599999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.2799999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.048,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.048,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.90529,
                0.91405
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.01959999999999991,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.006648119295999997,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.002304,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.1711072742346155,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.1711072742346155
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.1711072742346155,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "468c00075cfdff9f38eaa98ae7b6920d9ec77aa21996acd7fef522067dd0ff27",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:32:13Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:38Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.1448051449362208,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.13999999999999968,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-32c8f839e09e"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.465,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1685,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.16850 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.16849999999999987,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.23829498525986634,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08444799999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.2900/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.08444799999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.08444799999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.08444799999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.2899999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.01,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95466,
                0.96992
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.028392249999999956,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.007131464703999997,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.19065490999184875,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.19065490999184875
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.19065490999184875,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "ed3cd50c0bb6ac5d46670c4f865f1204be7a20ff0aef7fdce6d360fae695cb36",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:32:14Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:38Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.17251312993508627,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.16849999999999987,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-860f6a57a0ff"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.35,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1676,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.16765 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1676499999999996,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.23709290373184885,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08444799999999998,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.2900/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.08444799999999998,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.08444799999999998,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.08444799999999998,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.2899999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.01,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0573552272727273,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.1147104545454546,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95466,
                0.96992
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.028106522499999866,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.007131464703999997,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0032896220955062018,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "nlte",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.19837638291769025,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.19837638291769025
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.19837638291769025,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "a009f24a1578c7573414c9c83a7418e9c089c0a7c07b9979295a2282c8c03e07",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:53:32Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:00:53Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.17850679145485213,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.1676499999999996,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.061303769015503475,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9ac31d7523ad"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.437,
      "sigma_stat": 0.158,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.15800 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1579999999999999,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.2234457428549489,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.09609599999999997,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.3300/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.09609599999999997,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.09609599999999997,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.09609599999999997,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.3299999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.007,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.007,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95466,
                0.96992
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.024963999999999965,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.009234441215999995,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            4.9000000000000005e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.18701075160535546,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.18701075160535546
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.18701075160535546,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "db5fb9acaf59aff79ef0787df80b71adf233297723c8e98c5097a3477d938646",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:32:21Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:31Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.16227301069493955,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.1579999999999999,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-17a68269f94a"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "near-UV",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
      "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.489,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1575,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1972,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 0,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.15750 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|near-UV|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|DEEPGRADED|DEEPGRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-deep-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.15749999999999975,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.22273863607376213,
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01603277892319357,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_81c4f09b829b",
                "pk_e324cf145c4a"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0128,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A; TP ref c30,T76n)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30,T76n)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.00016384,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08517599999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -0.2925/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.08517599999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.08517599999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.08517599999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.2924999999999999,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.0,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.0,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "paired_median_dex": -0.01,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 0.4,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "3000-3780 A contains no registered telluric band (pipeline.telluric_policy)",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "near-UV",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.95466,
                0.96992
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "3302.369": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 6,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 6,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.923,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                },
                "3302.978": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 4,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 4,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.903,
                  "synthesis_list": "data/linelists/ispec_nearuv_3000_3780/atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "DEEPGRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "e42e56ab1bd65823de6202b78e4f2356be3eb3bed7ef9da4d2c4ac067b19e058",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.024806249999999922,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00025705,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.007254950975999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.18134712839193215,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.18134712839193215
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_81c4f09b829b",
        "pk_e324cf145c4a"
      ],
      "grade": "Deep Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.18134712839193215,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_3000_3780_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_DEEPGRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "6a6142d28a3accb5499d6436c8a5c0a2d900883a9788ba01caef70bdcb3645f0",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:32:14Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:36:38Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.16178621696547554,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.15749999999999975,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-8da873b08ed4"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_iag",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.327,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1605,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 3,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.12566 dex at n_lines=5",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|iag_fts_solar_atlas|solar_iag|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1604921467445266,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.3209842934890532,
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01305335205991166,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021111999999999995,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.4750/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.021111999999999995,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.021111999999999995,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.021111999999999995,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.07249999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.32190837205639744,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.112,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.317,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.272,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.272,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0012564980111408359,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 7373.231,
                  "dA_df": -605.0000000000005,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9972999892778223,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06316383714837914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -5.000000000000782,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.005025992044563343,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_iag vs independent correction solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0010051984089125116
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -70.99999999999973,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98013,
                0.99718,
                1.00359,
                1.00988
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.025757729166666663,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00017038999999999997,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0004457165439999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.103625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.07398400000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            1.578787252000876e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.45216473159449166,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.45216473159449166
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.45216473159449166,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_iag_fts_solar_atlas_solar_iag_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_iag_fts_solar_atlas_solar_iag_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "9c6192bdd96ba31bdd75415e4d97ad2184d71cda036cc762c43a35623c1c4ed0",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:43:02Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:44:21Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.16470051355920742,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.1604921467445266,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-490ef3c9753d"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_iag",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 5.99,
      "sigma_stat": 0.2591,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 3,
      "dominant_term": "line-to-line scatter",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.17972 dex at n_lines=3",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|iag_fts_solar_atlas|solar_iag|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2590993181818182,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.36642176977434915,
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.025388580109962824,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 1.6474639999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates -5.6575/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -1.6474639999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -1.6474639999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 1.6474639999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -5.657499999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.8175234323858859,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.2615,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.807,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.409,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.409,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 7373.231,
                  "dA_df": -605.0000000000005,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9972999892778223,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06316383714837914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -70.99999999999973,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0069081818181818,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98013,
                0.99718
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "0c3b71c6f455b08e8fe97ead9d84cc696bbf2f3a21f163f1d09b047080c62704",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.06713245668228307,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00064458,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.7141376312959986,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.6683445625000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.16728099999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 1.9023429660495716,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 1.9023429660495716
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 1.9023429660495716,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_iag_fts_solar_atlas_solar_iag_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_iag_fts_solar_atlas_solar_iag_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "95f0fa38f9a50fe96bd28c23cecd677c46966bc2b577ff90277bf059dab56a55",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:59:10Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:12Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.2617269315188696,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.2590993181818182,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-29aa33878906"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_iag",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.332,
      "sigma_stat": 0.1706,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 3,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.13374 dex at n_lines=5",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|iag_fts_solar_atlas|solar_iag|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.17064748020407453,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.34129496040814905,
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01305335205991166,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.020383999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.4750/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.020383999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.020383999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.020383999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.06999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.3181010059713738,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.073,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.316,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2665,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2665,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0012564980111406127,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 7373.231,
                  "dA_df": -599.9999999999997,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9972999892778223,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06316383714837914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.005025992044562451,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_iag vs independent correction solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0010051984089125116
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -71.00000000000061,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98013,
                0.99718,
                1.00359,
                1.00988
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "82716c5a50337a57ae99cc45b0788c14aa480f91488f32a20a5eefa09dec5bb0",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.029120562500000006,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00017038999999999997,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0004155074559999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.10118825,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.07102225000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            1.5787872520003153e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.4498745033264855,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.4498745033264855
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.4498745033264855,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_iag_fts_solar_atlas_solar_iag_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_iag_fts_solar_atlas_solar_iag_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "6efb2e0a02c2f319c7dd5261ebd2760d770d6464a91bb6761860bc14a5a8fa1f",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:42:58Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:44:20Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.17461126109160316,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.17064748020407453,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-81cf47912679"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.322,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0447,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 3,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.04465 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.044653060738692185,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.08930612147738437,
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.010830050784737807,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008735999999999997,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0425/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.008735999999999997,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.008735999999999997,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.008735999999999997,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.029999999999999992,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.3256412903794603,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.22,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.3065,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1925,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.1925,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0028546774812062523,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.011418709924825009,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected vs independent correction solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0022837419849650506
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -5.000000000000782,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -71.00000000000061,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -78.00000000000028,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.97975,
                0.98239,
                0.99643,
                1.00094
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0019938958333333336,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00011728999999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            7.631769599999995e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.10604225,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.03705625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.149183521706073e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.38178879333062543,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.38178879333062543
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.38178879333062543,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "0a7a7662b8754cd3a17621192e2f9b17ff730a66009049f7be579b67d483ed45",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:43:12Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:44:21Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.057986428009779455,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.044653060738692185,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-256c3fc7e0b8"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.231,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0213,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 2,
      "n_excluded": 2,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.02135 dex at n_lines=2",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021349999999999977,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "n_components": 2,
              "raw_sigma": 0.03019345955666555,
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.020788939366884494,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.5,
                0.5
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 2 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0075/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0021839999999999993,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.007499999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.6919075082697109,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.44,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.656,
              "n_paired": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0945,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.0945,
              "n_paired": 2,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -71.00000000000061,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -78.00000000000028,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0070581818181818,
              "n_lines": 2,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.97975,
                0.98239
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "908773e31de941ccad36bdaf9d5d03d358da73e88dc19dac623f30e308fdc644",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.000455822499999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0004321799999999999,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            4.769855999999997e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.4787360000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00893025,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.6999482497699384,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.6999482497699384
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.6999482497699384,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "26259d79f84127bba3cf1db1734c420c58d56719dd909f9d7be9c4a21aa2a6b7",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:59:26Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:13Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.04271243963999248,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.021349999999999977,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-7699e2dbb81f"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.271,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0726,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 3,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.07257 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.07256548766459157,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.14513097532918315,
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.010830050784737807,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0100/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.37301608544404624,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.258,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.35,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.172,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.172,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.004567483969930106,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -8.000000000000007,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.018269935879720423,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected vs independent correction solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0022837419849650506
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -12.9999999999999,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -97.99999999999986,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -84.99999999999996,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.97975,
                0.98239,
                0.99643,
                1.00094
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.005265749999999992,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00011728999999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.13914100000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.029583999999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.0861909815568478e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.41785111205525777,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.41785111205525777
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.41785111205525777,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "c48288f8e402dd7783852be43821d3a18f0195cef2293465838ffff91fa83f5e",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:43:11Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:44:21Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.08145108961824878,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.07256548766459157,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-04067e028764"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.327,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0451,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 4,
      "n_excluded": 3,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.04506 dex at n_lines=4",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.04505829557362317,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 4,
              "n_components": 4,
              "raw_sigma": 0.09011659114724634,
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.010830050784737807,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25,
                0.25
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.008735999999999997,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 4 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0400/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.008735999999999997,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.008735999999999997,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.008735999999999997,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.029999999999999992,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.32517072438951206,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.22,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.306,
              "n_paired": 4
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.1835,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.1835,
              "n_paired": 4,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0028546774812062523,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.011418709924825009,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected vs independent correction solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0022837419849650506
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -70.99999999999973,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -76.99999999999996,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.97975,
                0.98239,
                0.99643,
                1.00094
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "95c0c45202f90266da413ccbe7fb4871f3dd98884a2f336f471966fbff8a56fc",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.002030249999999989,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00011728999999999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            7.631769599999995e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.10573600000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.03367225,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            8.149183521706073e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.3769731911947078,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.3769731911947078
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.3769731911947078,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "05bd4e6bf3e59767a6276cf4d862518e15e7c6e138c8ce7e067c829c63642732",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:43:07Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:44:21Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.05829905659614048,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.04505829557362317,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0e50a7927295"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "1D-LTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE",
      "A": 6.364,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0549,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 5,
      "n_excluded": 2,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.05485 dex at n_lines=5",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|1D-LTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.05485216495271632,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 5,
              "n_components": 5,
              "raw_sigma": 0.12265316954730524,
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01198432309310793,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.016015999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 5 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0550/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.016015999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.016015999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.016015999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.05499999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.22130578392803021,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.127,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.212,
              "n_paired": 5
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.212,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.212,
              "n_paired": 5,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.002584639601438253,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 7373.231,
                  "dA_df": -173.00000000000003,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9972999892778223,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06316383714837914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -5.999999999999339,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.012923198007191265,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0021538663345321146
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -68.99999999999994,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -78.99999999999973,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98266,
                0.98548,
                0.99616,
                0.99849,
                1.01737
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.00300876,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.000143624,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00025651225599999987,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.04897625,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.044944,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            6.680361869322892e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.312736880808563,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.312736880808563
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.312736880808563,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_products.csv",
        "sha256": "f2ca2087372080b7c019ccaa73b85c7dbf7f56336c2c5512e24a287bd55cebb4",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:43:24Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:44:22Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.06616109128483298,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.05485216495271632,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-2755c55a0874"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Amarsi",
      "A": 6.262,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0664,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 3,
      "n_excluded": 2,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.06644 dex at n_lines=3",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-A|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.06643894124945128,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "n_components": 3,
              "raw_sigma": 0.11507562184513327,
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.019558118518916895,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333,
                0.3333333333333333
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 3 lines; difference of aggregates 0.0150/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_plus_dex": 0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_minus_dex": -0.004367999999999999,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": 0.014999999999999996,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.6129390263313309,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.269,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.598,
              "n_paired": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.089,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.089,
              "n_paired": 3,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 7373.231,
                  "dA_df": -173.00000000000003,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9972999892778223,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06316383714837914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -68.99999999999994,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -78.99999999999973,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.03,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the non-LTE abundance correction, minimum 0.03 dex -- the correction measured on this pool (median 1D-NLTE delta of the accepted lines)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348",
              "median_nlte_correction_dex": -0.0069081818181818,
              "n_lines": 3,
              "floor_dex": 0.03
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98266,
                0.98548,
                0.99616
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "every pool line has hfs_n_components == 1 (canonical_gf)",
            "evidence": {
              "hfs_n_components": [
                1
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "d2b3fa9d2e438b0459262e08917b9663915656da54cf6d8724724697b22af348",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0044141329143480386,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.00038252,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            1.9079423999999988e-05,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.37569424999999995,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.007921,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0009,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "nlte",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.6243392606094447,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.6243392606094447
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.6243392606094447,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-A_products.csv",
        "sha256": "9a523cf44b004c347f433943a812bff07620452f9f609b8f388fad2cb5b3634a",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-27T14:59:43Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-27T15:01:14Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.07604382232862865,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.06643894124945128,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-352e51858fa7"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-NLTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.338,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0826,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 5,
      "n_excluded": 2,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.08263 dex at n_lines=5",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|ENGINE-B-NLTE|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.08262808239333647,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 5,
              "n_components": 5,
              "raw_sigma": 0.18476200908195387,
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01198432309310793,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 5 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0250/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.0014559999999999996,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.004999999999999998,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.22474708007002003,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.101,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.219,
              "n_paired": 5
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.2,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.2,
              "n_paired": 5,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0017230930676258847,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 7373.231,
                  "dA_df": -168.00000000000014,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9972999892778223,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06316383714837914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -4.000000000000448,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.008615465338129423,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0021538663345321146
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -1.9999999999997797,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -105.00000000000043,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -79.99999999999918,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98266,
                0.98548,
                0.99616,
                0.99849,
                1.01737
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0068274,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.000143624,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.1199359999999987e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.050511249999999994,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.04000000000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            2.969049719700382e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.31297906157716,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.31297906157716
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.31297906157716,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_ENGINE-B-NLTE_products.csv",
        "sha256": "7b28a5ac2706253dd736b91b55c912684f738c83a25490130e15d36172120ac7",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T20:37:25Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T20:38:49Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.09053137577657815,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.08262808239333647,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-aa11fabbd085"
    },
    {
      "element": "Na",
      "ion": "I",
      "band": "red-optical",
      "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
      "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
      "tier": "GRADED",
      "selector": "GRADED",
      "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
      "display": "Synth · 1D-LTE · Gerber",
      "A": 6.37,
      "sigma_stat": 0.0547,
      "sigma_syst": 0.1726,
      "n_lines": 5,
      "n_excluded": 2,
      "dominant_term": "gf scale (UNGRADED)",
      "stat_basis": "measured — RMS of the random terms, 0.05473 dex at n_lines=5",
      "route": "SYNTH",
      "uncertainty": {
        "schema": "rya587.uncertainty.v1",
        "scope": {
          "star": "solar",
          "product_key": "Na|I|red-optical|kpno_solar_atlas|solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected|GRADED|GRADED|SYNTH|synth-1D-LTE-gerber|our-graded",
          "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db"
        },
        "components": [
          {
            "name": "measurement",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.05472695862187117,
            "source": "per-feature scatter of the accepted pool (components within 0.5 A merged, RYA-1232)",
            "evidence": {
              "method": "line_scatter",
              "independent": true,
              "n_lines": 5,
              "n_components": 5,
              "raw_sigma": 0.12237319968032216,
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "transition_data",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.01198432309310793,
            "source": "gf covariance per data/reference/gf_error_model.csv -- NIST_ASD: scale_only (scale 0.0000 dex; NIST ASD accuracy classes; Kelleher & Podobedova 2008 JPCRD 37)",
            "evidence": {
              "indicator_ids": [
                "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
                "pk_c983ab43cad5",
                "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
                "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
                "pk_c5678cc4e293"
              ],
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "line_sigma_dex": [
                0.0414,
                0.0086,
                0.0086,
                0.0294,
                0.0294
              ],
              "weights": [
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2,
                0.2
              ],
              "line_sources": [
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy A+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)",
                "NIST ASD (accuracy B+; TP ref c30)"
              ],
              "covariance": [
                [
                  0.0017139599999999998,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.396e-05,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0008643599999999999
                ]
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.logg",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar log g is pinned; delta_logg is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.metallicity",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "solar [Fe/H] is pinned; delta_feh is definitionally zero (RYA-1089)",
            "evidence": {
              "delta": 0.0,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.teff",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "sourced DEFINED zero (RYA-1226 convention): the solar Teff allowance is 1 K",
            "evidence": {
              "parameter_exists": true,
              "delta_K": 1.0,
              "owed_measurement": "a Teff perturbation on this pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "stellar.xi",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.017471999999999994,
            "source": "per-line paired differential at xi 0.90/1.10 on this product's OWN pool, stamped legs (RYA-1178 A)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "parameter_source": "RYA-1089 sourced solar delta_xi = 0.2912 km/s",
              "response_assessment": "central paired median over 5 lines; difference of aggregates -0.0600/km/s",
              "signed_response_dex": -0.017471999999999994,
              "delta_plus_dex": -0.017471999999999994,
              "delta_minus_dex": 0.017471999999999994,
              "delta_parameter": 0.2912,
              "dA_dxi": -0.059999999999999984,
              "parameter_exists": true
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "continuum",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.21380364823828427,
            "source": "standing continuum rule (synthesis reference, 3-MAD clipped): placement = q97 vs q80 central half-difference, REFERENCE = IAG-atlas leg minus nominal, in quadrature, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "paired_median_q97_minus_q80": 0.128,
              "paired_median_iag_minus_synthesis": 0.204,
              "n_paired": 5
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "profile_ew",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.202,
            "source": "fit window +/-0.25 A core vs the band's fixed window, paired on this pool",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "paired_median_dex": 0.202,
              "n_paired": 5,
              "varied": "fit half-width",
              "nominal_A": 1.1,
              "alternate_A": 0.25
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "telluric",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0021538663345320687,
            "source": "per-line measured sky depth -> measured residual of this holding vs an independent correction on the telluric pixels -> dex via the line's own dA/df (+0.1% leg); lines independent, weight 1/n",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "per_line": [
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 7373.231,
                  "dA_df": -168.00000000000014,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9972999892778223,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.06316383714837914,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8183.256,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.010769331672660344,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9818714452339444,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 14,
                  "max_depth": 0.25993160841925145,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.007793147580974001,
                  "residual_basis": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected vs independent correction solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected, baseline-removed",
                  "residual_flux": 0.0021538663345321146
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8194.824,
                  "dA_df": -4.999999999999893,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 0.9914251354676917,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.04259991988511336,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8649.931,
                  "dA_df": -70.00000000000028,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0031129209151413,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.002106620742926557,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                },
                {
                  "wavelength_air_A": 8650.897,
                  "dA_df": -77.9999999999994,
                  "sigma_line_dex": 0.0,
                  "sky_pair": "solar_kpno/solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
                  "clean_edge": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "clean_window_null": 0.16768564509441747,
                  "sky_baseline": 1.0029634967441,
                  "n_px": 400,
                  "n_telluric_px": 0,
                  "max_depth": 0.0029399425217802033,
                  "residual_flux": 0.0,
                  "sky_absorption": 0.0
                }
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "blends",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "full atomic + molecular synthesis in-window (RYA-1230 turned molecular opacity on in every band); no catalogued-blend deficit",
            "evidence": {
              "use_molecules": true,
              "owed_measurement": "a paired molecule-strength leg on this C/O pool"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "nlte",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "this leg applies no departures (nlte_delta_dex = 0 on every line)",
            "evidence": {
              "nlte_delta_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "pseudo_continuum",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "outside the near-UV the continuum is observed; it is placed per line by the standing rule and priced on `continuum`",
            "evidence": {
              "band": "red-optical",
              "continuum_levels": [
                0.98266,
                0.98548,
                0.99616,
                0.99849,
                1.01737
              ]
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "hfs_isotopes",
            "state": "DEFINED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "modelled: every hyperfine-split pool line is synthesised component by component from the band's synthesis list (lab HFS; as RYA-466/473 Cu, V, Mn and RYA-1217 Al); Asplund+2021 carries no HFS term",
            "evidence": {
              "lines": {
                "8194.821": {
                  "n_components_canonical": 2,
                  "n_components_in_synthesis": 2,
                  "max_component_depth": 0.61,
                  "synthesis_list": "atomic_lines.tsv"
                }
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "molecular_coupling",
            "state": "N/A",
            "sigma_dex": null,
            "source": "atomic product; the selector is not a MOL- indicator set",
            "evidence": {
              "selector": "GRADED"
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "holding_instrument",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.0,
            "source": "SynthesisHandler harness residual MEASURED against the known optical answer (RYA-869)",
            "evidence": {
              "harness_residual_dex": 0.0
            }
          },
          {
            "name": "model_atmosphere",
            "state": "MEASURED",
            "sigma_dex": 0.021645553815968804,
            "source": "Asplund+2021 Sect. 2.1: half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per-line LTE abundances of Scott+2015 I/II (atomic C/N/O: Asplund+2021 Table 3) (species mean (no pool line in Scott), n=5)",
            "evidence": {
              "pool_sha256": "3858077cf1d82af190edc988af04156b9a692cd41ce398a8422cf07c02bd85db",
              "temperature_structure_dex": 0.01930000000000014,
              "inhomogeneity_dex": 0.009799999999999809,
              "mean_3Dmean_minus_HM_dex": -0.03860000000000028,
              "mean_3D_minus_3Dmean_dex": -0.019599999999999618,
              "n_scott_lines": 5,
              "basis": "species mean (no pool line in Scott)",
              "scott_wavelengths_A": [
                4751.822,
                5148.838,
                6154.225,
                6160.747,
                10746.44
              ]
            }
          }
        ],
        "required_extra": [],
        "covariance": [
          [
            0.0029950399999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.000143624,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0003052707839999998,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.045711999999999996,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.04080400000000001,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            4.639140187030609e-06,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.00046853000000000167
          ]
        ],
        "covariance_order": [
          "measurement",
          "transition_data",
          "stellar.logg",
          "stellar.metallicity",
          "stellar.teff",
          "stellar.xi",
          "continuum",
          "profile_ew",
          "telluric",
          "hfs_isotopes",
          "holding_instrument",
          "model_atmosphere"
        ],
        "covariance_source": "components independent of one another; the shared-source gf correlation lives inside transition_data",
        "assumptions": "solar log g and [Fe/H] pinned; Teff allowance 1 K",
        "state": "COMPLETE",
        "holds": [],
        "sigma_reported": 0.30072097353558,
        "sigma_measured_partial": 0.30072097353558
      },
      "uncertainty_indicator_ids": [
        "pk_fbf9f22e6410",
        "pk_c983ab43cad5",
        "pk_5d58ed0a9259",
        "pk_ff7cc977c3d8",
        "pk_c5678cc4e293"
      ],
      "grade": "Codex Grade",
      "sigma_reported": 0.30072097353558,
      "provenance": {
        "host": "Mac",
        "path": "/Users/ryanschmitt/codex/rya1251/data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "copied_to": "data/results/orchestrator/budget/solar_Na/stage/NaI_6910_9199_kpno_solar_atlas_solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected_SYNTH_GRADED_synth-1D-LTE-gerber_products.csv",
        "sha256": "750925b61426532acbf9e0278a3ef0b705bc4039dfffeb9f327dc4b3a55f33fd",
        "artifact_mtime": "2026-10-25T12:43:18Z",
        "ingested_at": "2026-10-25T12:44:22Z"
      },
      "star": "solar",
      "sigma_asplund": 0.06605732359095395,
      "sigma_asplund_basis": "Asplund, Amarsi & Grevesse 2021 Sect. 2.1: statistical (+) half the mean (<3D> - Holweger & Mueller 1974) (+) half the mean (3D - <3D>), per line from Scott+2015 I/II (+) NLTE (half the correction, floor 0.03); molecules: Amarsi+2021 compositional term instead of NLTE, trend term not priced; atomic data and observational terms not included",
      "sigma_asplund_stat": 0.05472695862187117,
      "sigma_asplund_syst": 0.03699364810342448,
      "publication_id": "Na-products-af83ab9b05b0"
    }
  ],
  "body_html": "<p class=\"fe-anchor\">Solar sodium: 6.313 &plusmn; 0.039</p><p class=\"fe-anchor-reference\">Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse 2021: 6.22 &plusmn; 0.03 &nbsp;&middot;&nbsp; this measurement +0.093 dex</p><p class=\"fe-anchor-caveat\">The three-dimensional non-LTE products apply published line-by-line corrections (Asplund et al. 2021; Canocchi et al. 2026) to our one-dimensional fits; they are not our own three-dimensional calculation. The H- and K-band products sit about 0.4 dex below the visible ones. They are shown as measured, with their full error bars.</p><p>Measured the way Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse (2021) measure it: the Asplund et al. 2021 line set (the five Na I lines of their Table A.1), 5 lines measured on one spectrum, each part weighted by its uncertainty.</p><ul class=\"fe-anchor-families\"><li>Na I: 6.291 &plusmn; 0.048 &middot; Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) &middot; VIS &middot; Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)</li><li>Na I: 6.328 &plusmn; 0.040 &middot; Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) &middot; NIR &middot; Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)</li></ul><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>Highlighted Products</h2><div class=\"fe-highlights\"><article class=\"fe-highlight-uv\" data-highlight-product=\"Na-products-9e68e7906843\"><h3>near-UV</h3><strong>6.671 ± 0.141</strong><p>Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Deep Grade</p></article><article class=\"fe-highlight-visible\" data-highlight-product=\"Na-products-620b8337a6f5\"><h3>VIS</h3><strong>6.287 ± 0.047</strong><p>Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Reference Grade</p></article><article class=\"fe-highlight-visible\" data-highlight-product=\"Na-products-aa11fabbd085\"><h3>red-optical</h3><strong>6.338 ± 0.091</strong><p>Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Codex Grade</p></article><article class=\"fe-highlight-ir\" data-highlight-product=\"Na-products-c474eb26f3ae\"><h3>NIR</h3><strong>6.328 ± 0.040</strong><p>Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Reference Grade</p></article><article class=\"fe-highlight-ir\" data-highlight-product=\"Na-products-a80b76db5d6a\"><h3>H</h3><strong>5.779 ± 0.693</strong><p>Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · CRIRES+ H · Codex Grade</p></article><article class=\"fe-highlight-ir\" data-highlight-product=\"Na-products-4f1dee816393\"><h3>K</h3><strong>5.903 ± 0.137</strong><p>Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · CRIRES+ · Codex Grade</p></article></div></section><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>Line grades</h2><p class=\"product-section-intro\">Every product is measured on one of three grades of spectral lines and the grades are never mixed in one number.</p><div class=\"appendix-table-panel appendix-table-panel--grades\"><p class=\"appendix-table-hint\" id=\"grades-table-hint\">Scroll horizontally to read all columns &middot; focus the table and use the arrow keys</p><div class=\"appendix-table-scroll\" role=\"region\" tabindex=\"0\" aria-label=\"Line grades\" aria-describedby=\"grades-table-hint\"><table class=\"appendix-table appendix-table--grades\"><caption>Line grades</caption><thead><tr><th scope=\"col\">Grade</th><th scope=\"col\">What it means</th><th scope=\"col\">This element</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr data-grade=\"reference\"><th scope=\"row\">Reference Grade</th><td>lines from a published solar line set (Asplund et al. 2021 and similar), measured with the oscillator strengths the authors used</td><td>20 products -- Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines</td></tr><tr data-grade=\"codex\"><th scope=\"row\">Codex Grade</th><td>lines chosen by the Codex whose oscillator strength carries a published uncertainty (laboratory measurement, NIST accuracy class A-C, or the paper's own stated error), between 5% and 60% deep</td><td>44 products -- Na I · Codex-graded lines</td></tr><tr data-grade=\"deep\"><th scope=\"row\">Deep Grade</th><td>the same oscillator-strength rule on lines deeper than 60% -- stronger lines, more sensitive to damping and the model atmosphere</td><td>23 products -- Na I · Deep-graded lines</td></tr></tbody></table></div></div></section><section class=\"product-section\"><h2>Error-bar Forest Plot</h2><div class=\"product-forest\"><div class=\"product-forest-inner\"><div class=\"forest-band\">near-UV</div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-4d5f9acb10d8\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:52.920690%;width:40.881932%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:73.361655%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.689<small>±0.153</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-0c24e0ee234b\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:36.592963%;width:42.719173%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:57.952549%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.574<small>±0.159</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-9e68e7906843\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:52.000063%;width:37.899465%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:70.949795%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.671<small>±0.141</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-32c8f839e09e\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:57.174705%;width:38.805528%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:76.577469%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.713<small>±0.145</small></span></div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-860f6a57a0ff\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:20.231977%;width:46.230838%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:43.347396%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.465<small>±0.173</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-9ac31d7523ad\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:4.019767%;width:47.837046%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:27.938290%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.350<small>±0.179</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-17a68269f94a\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:17.852291%;width:43.486645%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:39.595614%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.437<small>±0.162</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-8da873b08ed4\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:6.499533%;width:8.039534%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:10.519300%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:19.898756%;width:2.679845%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:21.238678%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:24.885114%;width:43.356192%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:46.563210%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.489<small>±0.162</small></span></div><p class=\"forest-reference-note\">Green band: Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse 2021 photospheric reference, A(Na) = 6.22 &plusmn; 0.03, drawn behind every row. Yellow band: Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025, 6.30 &plusmn; 0.01 (present-day Sun).</p><div class=\"axis\"><span></span><span class=\"ticks\"><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:0%\">6.14</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:25%\">6.33</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:50%\">6.51</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:75%\">6.70</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:100%\">6.89</span></span><span class=\"forest-value\">A(Na) dex</span></div><div class=\"forest-band\">VIS</div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">HARPS</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-65aef47bc520\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:57.610618%;width:25.694660%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:70.457948%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.278<small>±0.052</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:54.064301%;width:25.910782%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:67.019692%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.264<small>±0.053</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-d70898a6d4f2\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:44.357440%;width:26.659685%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:57.687283%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.226<small>±0.054</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-9439cb57fb7e\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:53.624632%;width:26.298940%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:66.774102%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.263<small>±0.054</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-5919b5d71e97\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:58.574456%;width:25.731701%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:71.440307%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.282<small>±0.052</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-ab243f5f7fb7\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:48.548557%;width:19.259809%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:58.178462%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.228<small>±0.039</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-cd4f141ff187\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:42.813925%;width:36.132047%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:60.879949%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.239<small>±0.074</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-77cd03c01180\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:8.843507%;width:36.781301%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:27.234157%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.102<small>±0.075</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-252fafda80c1\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:46.092660%;width:19.259809%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:55.722565%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.218<small>±0.039</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-f7b85afbd89a\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:52.148218%;width:19.428180%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:61.862308%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.243<small>±0.040</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-4c88219f1ea2\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:51.731177%;width:39.909440%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:71.685897%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.283<small>±0.081</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-034d202da814\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 6 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:44.849364%;width:44.340656%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:67.019692%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.264<small>±0.090</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-1a483ec17b8d\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:39.556364%;width:36.261837%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:57.687283%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.226<small>±0.074</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-a3583bba6864\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:49.804853%;width:34.920857%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:67.265282%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.265<small>±0.071</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-abce6000c004\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:52.704203%;width:39.928106%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:72.668256%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.287<small>±0.081</small></span></div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-b06ed066892d\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:64.231551%;width:23.258743%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.300<small>±0.047</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-620b8337a6f5\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:61.005814%;width:23.324883%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:72.668256%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.287<small>±0.047</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:51.241242%;width:23.698030%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:63.090256%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.248<small>±0.048</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-b90c5f56677b\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:60.143233%;width:23.576507%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:71.931486%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.284<small>±0.048</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-c00f6af0b401\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:65.452748%;width:23.272245%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:77.088871%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.305<small>±0.047</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-3549f0317ecb\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:54.357000%;width:18.448872%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:63.581436%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.250<small>±0.038</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-841d473766d8\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:48.065955%;width:35.942757%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:66.037333%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.260<small>±0.073</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-b72a4b06a2c1\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:9.379627%;width:36.691419%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:27.725337%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.104<small>±0.075</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-b1a83c053f0b\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:50.339473%;width:19.607413%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:60.143180%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.236<small>±0.040</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-58dd461d3e5a\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:57.570122%;width:18.407961%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:66.774102%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.263<small>±0.037</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-5a5ee22946b5\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:62.236037%;width:22.337975%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:73.405025%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.290<small>±0.045</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-be7b30000a66\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 6 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:60.376013%;width:24.584485%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:72.668256%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.287<small>±0.050</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-23bfd23782d9\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:50.628161%;width:22.468293%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:61.862308%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.243<small>±0.046</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-17cc53288fb1\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:58.557060%;width:22.328238%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:69.721179%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.275<small>±0.045</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-36b16e0d3bcd\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:63.461856%;width:22.342236%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:74.632973%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.295<small>±0.045</small></span></div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-bf622c820458\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:65.194639%;width:23.297284%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:76.843281%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.304<small>±0.047</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:61.972507%;width:23.356215%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:73.650614%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.291<small>±0.048</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-fd002196b613\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:52.217187%;width:23.710858%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:64.072615%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.252<small>±0.048</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-0276917cf012\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:58.493691%;width:23.928515%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:70.457948%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.278<small>±0.049</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-6d05db230769\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:66.401248%;width:23.339962%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:78.071229%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.309<small>±0.048</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-dd0066591b38\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:46.829429%;width:19.259809%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:56.459334%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.221<small>±0.039</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-eb26cb8b60bb\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:41.094797%;width:36.132047%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:59.160821%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.232<small>±0.074</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-6f4bd45a4765\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Deep Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:7.367692%;width:36.294675%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:25.515029%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.095<small>±0.074</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-a5cee5792af3\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:44.572726%;width:18.370242%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:53.757847%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.210<small>±0.037</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-93bab5e00805\" data-selector=\"DEEPGRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Deep Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:50.183500%;width:19.428180%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:59.897590%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.235<small>±0.040</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-eeac09562b71\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:63.446110%;width:21.882547%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:74.387384%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.294<small>±0.045</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-f8e30b062164\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 6 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:61.518385%;width:24.264459%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:73.650614%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.291<small>±0.049</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-6f7a1bf44b76\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:51.614527%;width:22.460279%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:62.844667%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.247<small>±0.046</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-8260a258557d\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:56.384450%;width:22.252843%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:67.510871%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.266<small>±0.045</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-aac4173b0ef6\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:48.846053%;width:14.735383%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:56.213744%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:73.405025%;width:4.911794%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:75.860922%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:64.427831%;width:21.883822%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:75.369743%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.298<small>±0.045</small></span></div><p class=\"forest-reference-note\">Green band: Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse 2021 photospheric reference, A(Na) = 6.22 &plusmn; 0.03, drawn behind every row. Yellow band: Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025, 6.30 &plusmn; 0.01 (present-day Sun).</p><div class=\"axis\"><span></span><span class=\"ticks\"><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:0%\">5.99</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:25%\">6.09</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:50%\">6.19</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:75%\">6.30</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:100%\">6.40</span></span><span class=\"forest-value\">A(Na) dex</span></div><div class=\"forest-band\">red-optical</div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">IAG FTS</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-490ef3c9753d\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:55.350743%;width:39.292141%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:74.996814%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.327<small>±0.165</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-29aa33878906\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:3.578508%;width:62.439463%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:34.798239%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.990<small>±0.262</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-81cf47912679\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:54.764971%;width:41.656521%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:75.593232%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.332<small>±0.175</small></span></div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-256c3fc7e0b8\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:67.483566%;width:13.833660%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:74.400396%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.322<small>±0.058</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-7699e2dbb81f\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:58.450694%;width:10.189787%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:63.545588%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.231<small>±0.043</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-04067e028764\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:58.601152%;width:19.431559%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:68.316932%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.271<small>±0.081</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-0e50a7927295\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 4 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:68.042692%;width:13.908243%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:74.996814%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.327<small>±0.058</small></span></div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-2755c55a0874\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 5 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:71.518374%;width:15.783867%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:79.410307%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.364<small>±0.066</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-352e51858fa7\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 3 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:58.172598%;width:18.141562%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:67.243379%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.262<small>±0.076</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-aa11fabbd085\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 5 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:65.510025%;width:21.597817%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:76.308933%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.338<small>±0.091</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-af83ab9b05b0\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 5 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:58.654960%;width:7.157016%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:62.233468%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:70.583320%;width:2.385672%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:71.776156%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:72.246453%;width:15.759111%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:80.126009%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.370<small>±0.066</small></span></div><p class=\"forest-reference-note\">Green band: Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse 2021 photospheric reference, A(Na) = 6.22 &plusmn; 0.03, drawn behind every row. Yellow band: Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025, 6.30 &plusmn; 0.01 (present-day Sun).</p><div class=\"axis\"><span></span><span class=\"ticks\"><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:0%\">5.70</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:25%\">5.91</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:50%\">6.12</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:75%\">6.33</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:100%\">6.54</span></span><span class=\"forest-value\">A(Na) dex</span></div><div class=\"forest-band\">NIR</div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">CRIRES+ J</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-1229a0a156f8\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:17.530407%;width:78.217680%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:56.639247%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.213<small>±0.294</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-f1c4ef0ec48e\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:3.986169%;width:22.393843%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:15.183091%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.901<small>±0.084</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-65e9578f5f35\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:16.984590%;width:74.791656%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:54.380418%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.196<small>±0.281</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-448c77475a54\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:17.796151%;width:78.217680%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:56.904991%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.215<small>±0.294</small></span></div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">CRIRES+ Y (full arm)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-85aee27b99bb\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:38.468972%;width:12.423536%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:44.680740%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.123<small>±0.047</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-118aa2ad0c1e\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:36.077271%;width:12.423536%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:42.289039%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.105<small>±0.047</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-81eca203f5c6\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:35.544000%;width:14.287311%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:42.687656%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.108<small>±0.054</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-6637f12ec02e\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:38.332466%;width:12.430803%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:44.547868%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.122<small>±0.047</small></span></div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit)</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-18e5094f3c43\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE<small>Reference Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:63.075010%;width:10.513997%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:68.332009%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.301<small>±0.040</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-c474eb26f3ae\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:66.662562%;width:10.513997%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:71.919560%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.328<small>±0.040</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-bb8baa1178c8\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Reference Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:62.277776%;width:10.513997%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:67.534775%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.295<small>±0.040</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-bf2a2938353f\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:39.606282%;width:48.150392%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:63.681478%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.266<small>±0.181</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-dc40cd57490f\" data-selector=\"SET-NA_AGSS21\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Reference Grade · 1 line</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:63.337967%;width:10.519571%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:68.597753%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.303<small>±0.040</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-bdcd99128c04\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 3 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:41.692550%;width:40.257432%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:61.821266%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.252<small>±0.151</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-bd12d76eaf22\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 2 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:14.525104%;width:45.429576%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:37.239892%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.067<small>±0.171</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-c0ce41acfee8\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 3 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:39.736588%;width:38.854465%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:59.163820%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.232<small>±0.146</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-186caf770fd6\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 3 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:53.583184%;width:7.972338%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:57.569353%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:66.870413%;width:2.657446%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:68.199136%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:41.550470%;width:40.275847%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:61.688394%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">6.251<small>±0.152</small></span></div><p class=\"forest-reference-note\">Green band: Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse 2021 photospheric reference, A(Na) = 6.22 &plusmn; 0.03, drawn behind every row. Yellow band: Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025, 6.30 &plusmn; 0.01 (present-day Sun).</p><div class=\"axis\"><span></span><span class=\"ticks\"><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:0%\">5.79</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:25%\">5.97</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:50%\">6.16</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:75%\">6.35</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:100%\">6.54</span></span><span class=\"forest-value\">A(Na) dex</span></div><div class=\"forest-band\">H</div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">CRIRES+ H</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-fb210d1eee02\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 3 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:76.078912%;width:4.025775%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:78.091800%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:82.788538%;width:1.341925%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:83.459500%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:3.175715%;width:92.934544%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:49.642987%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.796<small>±0.693</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-a80b76db5d6a\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 3 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:76.078912%;width:4.025775%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:78.091800%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:82.788538%;width:1.341925%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:83.459500%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:2.012888%;width:92.978925%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:48.502350%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.779<small>±0.693</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-c047829fd0f2\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 3 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:76.078912%;width:4.025775%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:78.091800%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:82.788538%;width:1.341925%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:83.459500%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:2.238209%;width:95.748904%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:50.112660%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.803<small>±0.714</small></span></div><p class=\"forest-reference-note\">Green band: Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse 2021 photospheric reference, A(Na) = 6.22 &plusmn; 0.03, drawn behind every row. Yellow band: Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025, 6.30 &plusmn; 0.01 (present-day Sun).</p><div class=\"axis\"><span></span><span class=\"ticks\"><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:0%\">5.06</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:25%\">5.43</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:50%\">5.80</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:75%\">6.17</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:100%\">6.55</span></span><span class=\"forest-value\">A(Na) dex</span></div><div class=\"forest-band\">K</div><div class=\"forest-instrument\">CRIRES+</div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-0552befecb14\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:75.790928%;width:9.683629%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:80.632742%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:91.930309%;width:3.227876%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:93.544247%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:4.841814%;width:47.644237%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:28.663933%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.898<small>±0.148</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-4f1dee816393\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:75.790928%;width:9.683629%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:80.632742%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:91.930309%;width:3.227876%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:93.544247%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:7.402635%;width:44.136534%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:29.470902%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.903<small>±0.137</small></span></div><div class=\"forest\" data-product-id=\"Na-products-caab8cbc99e0\" data-selector=\"GRADED\" data-line-set=\"\"><span class=\"forest-label\">Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber)<small>Codex Grade · 7 lines</small></span><span class=\"track\"><i class=\"ref\" style=\"left:75.790928%;width:9.683629%\"></i><i class=\"refline\" style=\"left:80.632742%\"></i><i class=\"cmpband\" title=\"Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025\" style=\"left:91.930309%;width:3.227876%\"></i><i class=\"cmp\" style=\"left:93.544247%\"></i><i class=\"bar\" style=\"left:5.180349%;width:47.289956%\"></i><i class=\"dot\" style=\"left:28.825327%\"></i></span><span class=\"forest-value\">5.899<small>±0.147</small></span></div><p class=\"forest-reference-note\">Green band: Asplund, Amarsi &amp; Grevesse 2021 photospheric reference, A(Na) = 6.22 &plusmn; 0.03, drawn behind every row. Yellow band: Lodders, Bergemann &amp; Palme 2025, 6.30 &plusmn; 0.01 (present-day Sun).</p><div class=\"axis\"><span></span><span class=\"ticks\"><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:0%\">5.72</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:25%\">5.88</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:50%\">6.03</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:75%\">6.19</span><span class=\"tick\" style=\"left:100%\">6.34</span></span><span class=\"forest-value\">A(Na) dex</span></div></div></div><p class=\"product-section-intro\"><strong>How to read this forest.</strong> Each row is one independent product, preserving its band, holding, engine, indicator and line set. Engines and indicator families are never averaged. Each bar is the uncertainty as Asplund et al. 2021 quote it: line-to-line scatter, the 3D-model term and the NLTE term (at least 0.03 dex). For a molecule the NLTE term is replaced by its dependence on the other element, and the 3D term comes from the 3D-to-1D difference Amarsi et al. 2021 publish for the same band. Atomic-data and observational terms are not in the bar, as in Asplund; they stay in the full error budget attached to the row. Grades describe the supplied line-pool provenance, not engine quality; evaluated theoretical CNO oscillator strengths are not relabelled as laboratory evidence. Quarantined, failed and unconstrained fits have no abundance mark. Experimental products remain explicitly not adopted. Literature references provide context, never tuning targets. <span class=\"deep-grade-key\">Yellow rows are Deep Grade: strong lines that saturate, kept but less certain than the other grades.</span></p></section><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>How this was measured</h2><p class=\"product-section-intro\">Every sodium value on this page comes from fitting synthetic spectra to the observed solar spectrum, line by line or band by band, with the sodium abundance as the free parameter. The synthesis includes the atomic lines and the molecular opacity in every window, so blended absorption is modelled rather than attributed to the line being measured. The continuum is placed locally around every line by comparing the observation with the synthesis on its own highest pixels, and ground-based spectra are telluric-corrected across their full range.</p><p class=\"product-section-intro\">Each indicator is measured independently on each solar spectrum and reported separately; nothing is averaged across indicators or instruments. Where a 3D or NLTE correction is published for the lines, it is applied as its own product (1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE and 3D-NLTE are separate rows). Every value carries a full uncertainty budget: fit, line strengths, microturbulence, continuum, fit window, model atmosphere, telluric residual, and the spread between spectra, each measured by refitting with that one input changed. The headline at the top is the Asplund-grade product: a published line set, the most complete treatment, then the most lines.</p><div class=\"appendix-table-panel appendix-table-panel--measurement\"><p class=\"appendix-table-hint\" id=\"measurement-table-hint\">Scroll horizontally to read all columns &middot; focus the table and use the arrow keys</p><div class=\"appendix-table-scroll\" role=\"region\" tabindex=\"0\" aria-label=\"Measurement summary\" aria-describedby=\"measurement-table-hint\"><table class=\"appendix-table appendix-table--measurement\"><caption>Measurement summary</caption><thead><tr><th scope=\"col\">Band</th><th scope=\"col\">What was measured</th><th scope=\"col\">Solar spectra</th><th scope=\"col\">Treatments</th><th scope=\"col\">Lines</th><th scope=\"col\">Result A(Na)</th><th scope=\"col\">Largest uncertainty terms (dex)</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><th scope=\"row\">near-UV</th><td>Na I · Deep-graded lines</td><td>Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit), Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">2</td><td class=\"num\">6.350–6.671 <small>(1D-NLTE)</small></td><td>fit / line-to-line scatter 0.14, microturbulence 0.08</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">VIS</th><td>Na I · Deep-graded lines</td><td>HARPS, Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit), Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE, 3D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">1–2</td><td class=\"num\">6.232–6.260 <small>(3D-NLTE)</small></td><td>fit window 0.32, NLTE / 3D correction 0.07</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">VIS</th><td>Na I · Codex-graded lines</td><td>HARPS, Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit), Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE, 3D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">6–7</td><td class=\"num\">6.264–6.291 <small>(3D-NLTE)</small></td><td>fit / line-to-line scatter 0.03, NLTE / 3D correction 0.03</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">VIS</th><td>Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines</td><td>HARPS, Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit), Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE, 3D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">4</td><td class=\"num\">6.264–6.291 <small>(3D-NLTE)</small></td><td>continuum placement 0.04, NLTE / 3D correction 0.03</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">red-optical</th><td>Na I · Codex-graded lines</td><td>IAG FTS, Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit), Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005)</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">2–5</td><td class=\"num\">5.990–6.338 <small>(1D-NLTE)</small></td><td>continuum placement 0.22, fit window 0.20</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">NIR</th><td>Na I · Codex-graded lines</td><td>CRIRES+ J, CRIRES+ Y (full arm), Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit)</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">1–3</td><td class=\"num\">5.901–6.232 <small>(1D-NLTE)</small></td><td>fit / line-to-line scatter 0.14, fit window 0.07</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">NIR</th><td>Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines</td><td>Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit)</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE, 3D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">1</td><td class=\"num\">6.328 <small>(3D-NLTE)</small></td><td>NLTE / 3D correction 0.03, fit / line-to-line scatter 0.02</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">H</th><td>Na I · Codex-graded lines</td><td>CRIRES+ H</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">3</td><td class=\"num\">5.779 <small>(1D-NLTE)</small></td><td>fit / line-to-line scatter 0.69, telluric residual 0.54</td></tr><tr><th scope=\"row\">K</th><td>Na I · Codex-graded lines</td><td>CRIRES+</td><td>1D-LTE, 1D-NLTE</td><td class=\"num\">7</td><td class=\"num\">5.903 <small>(1D-NLTE)</small></td><td>fit / line-to-line scatter 0.13, telluric residual 0.12</td></tr></tbody></table></div></div></section><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>Excluded lines</h2><p class=\"product-section-intro\">These lines are left out of the Sun's measurement. They stay in the line lists: a cooler or more evolved star may measure them well. Blended lines are not excluded -- the spectrum synthesis models the blend. 1 lines.</p><ul></ul><div class=\"appendix-table-panel appendix-table-panel--exclusions\"><p class=\"appendix-table-hint\" id=\"exclusions-table-hint\">Scroll horizontally to read all columns &middot; focus the table and use the arrow keys</p><div class=\"appendix-table-scroll\" role=\"region\" tabindex=\"0\" aria-label=\"Excluded lines\" aria-describedby=\"exclusions-table-hint\"><table class=\"appendix-table appendix-table--exclusions\"><caption>Excluded lines</caption><thead><tr><th scope=\"col\">Species</th><th scope=\"col\">Wavelength (Å, air)</th><th scope=\"col\">Why it is excluded</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Na I</td><td class=\"solar-number\">4242.081</td><td>atomic_blend</td></tr></tbody></table></div></div></section><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>Solar sodium context</h2><p>Sodium is traced by neutral Na I lines from the near-ultraviolet to the K band. The reference lines are the five Asplund et al. 2021 used (4751, 5148, 6154, 6160 and 10746 Å), with the oscillator strengths they adopted. Na I departs from LTE, so each spectrum also carries non-LTE products; each set, spectrum and treatment remains a separate product.</p><p><a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv\">Published line sets</a> · <a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/reference/gf_error_model.csv\">gf uncertainty model</a> · <a href=\"/method/\">Methodology</a></p></section><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>Download the evidence</h2><p><a download href=\"/assets/docs/appendices/solar_na_appendix.pdf\">Download PDF — Solar Na appendix</a></p><ul><li><a download href=\"/assets/data/cno-publication/Na/Na.json\">Source feed — includes quarantined fit outputs, not adopted abundances</a></li><li><a download href=\"/assets/data/cno-publication/Na/visibility.json\">Complete product visibility audit</a></li><li><a download href=\"/assets/data/cno-publication/Na/report.json\">Shared website/PDF report</a></li><li><a download href=\"/assets/data/cno-publication/Na/manifest.json\">Reproducibility manifest</a></li><li><a download href=\"/assets/data/cno-publication/Na/references.json\">Complete references and product-to-source bindings</a></li></ul></section><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>Reproducibility</h2><p>Generated from the pinned science snapshot. Source commit <code>e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71</code><br>Feed Na.json v1.158 · updated 2026-11-04T01:32:12Z<br>Generated 2026-11-05T21:50:45-07:00 (source commit timestamp)<br>Feed SHA-256 <code>f402244800e12a2ce57c1ea71a7eb122e2d3eb378beb0172c55e56483438bfb8</code><br>Generator scripts/generate_cno_publication.py v1.0.0</p><p><a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/products/solar/Na.json\">Pinned scientific source</a></p></section><section class=\"fe-section\"><h2>References / Data &amp; Model Sources</h2><p>Sources are separated by their role. Registered grid lineage and quarantined diagnostics do not imply an adopted abundance or an applied correction.</p><p>See the source notes for the distinction between reference lineage and the treatment actually recorded in each feed entry.</p><details><summary>Science and provenance source notes</summary><p><strong>Solar abundance and indicator analyses.</strong> Solar Na comparison literature; not an adopted Codex abundance. Sources: <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>.</p><p><strong>Atomic data and gf authorities.</strong> Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product&#x27;s own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage). Sources: <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>.</p><p><strong>Model and grid sources.</strong> Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed. Sources: <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a>.</p><p><strong>Model and grid sources.</strong> Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv). Sources: <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a>.</p><p><strong>Model and grid sources.</strong> Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity. Sources: <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a>.</p><p><strong>Model and grid sources.</strong> Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity. Sources: <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a>.</p><p><strong>Solar abundance and indicator analyses.</strong> Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection). Sources: <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>.</p><p><strong>Model and grid sources.</strong> Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte Sources: <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a>.</p><p><strong>Model and grid sources.</strong> Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte Sources: <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>.</p></details><details><summary>Product-to-source index</summary><ul><li>H · CRIRES+ H · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-fb210d1eee02</code></small></li><li>H · CRIRES+ H · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-a80b76db5d6a</code></small></li><li>H · CRIRES+ H · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-c047829fd0f2</code></small></li><li>K · CRIRES+ · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-0552befecb14</code></small></li><li>K · CRIRES+ · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-4f1dee816393</code></small></li><li>K · CRIRES+ · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-caab8cbc99e0</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ J · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-1229a0a156f8</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ J · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-f1c4ef0ec48e</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ J · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-65e9578f5f35</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ J · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-448c77475a54</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ Y (full arm) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-85aee27b99bb</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ Y (full arm) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-118aa2ad0c1e</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ Y (full arm) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-81eca203f5c6</code></small></li><li>NIR · CRIRES+ Y (full arm) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-6637f12ec02e</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-18e5094f3c43</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-c474eb26f3ae</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a> <small><code>Na-products-bb8baa1178c8</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-bf2a2938353f</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-dc40cd57490f</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-bdcd99128c04</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-bd12d76eaf22</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-c0ce41acfee8</code></small></li><li>NIR · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-186caf770fd6</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-65aef47bc520</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a> <small><code>Na-products-d70898a6d4f2</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-9439cb57fb7e</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-5919b5d71e97</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-ab243f5f7fb7</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-cd4f141ff187</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-77cd03c01180</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-252fafda80c1</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-f7b85afbd89a</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-4c88219f1ea2</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-034d202da814</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a> <small><code>Na-products-1a483ec17b8d</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-a3583bba6864</code></small></li><li>VIS · HARPS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-abce6000c004</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-b06ed066892d</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-620b8337a6f5</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a> <small><code>Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-b90c5f56677b</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-c00f6af0b401</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-3549f0317ecb</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-841d473766d8</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-b72a4b06a2c1</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-b1a83c053f0b</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-58dd461d3e5a</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-5a5ee22946b5</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-be7b30000a66</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a> <small><code>Na-products-23bfd23782d9</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-17cc53288fb1</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-36b16e0d3bcd</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-bf622c820458</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a> <small><code>Na-products-fd002196b613</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-0276917cf012</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Asplund et al. 2021 lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-6d05db230769</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-dd0066591b38</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-eb26cb8b60bb</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-6f4bd45a4765</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-a5cee5792af3</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-93bab5e00805</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-eeac09562b71</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 3D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-canocchi2026\">[6]</a> <small><code>Na-products-f8e30b062164</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a> <small><code>Na-products-6f7a1bf44b76</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-8260a258557d</code></small></li><li>VIS · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-aac4173b0ef6</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-4d5f9acb10d8</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-0c24e0ee234b</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-9e68e7906843</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-32c8f839e09e</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-860f6a57a0ff</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-9ac31d7523ad</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-17a68269f94a</code></small></li><li>near-UV · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Deep-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-8da873b08ed4</code></small></li><li>red-optical · IAG FTS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-490ef3c9753d</code></small></li><li>red-optical · IAG FTS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-29aa33878906</code></small></li><li>red-optical · IAG FTS · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-81cf47912679</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-256c3fc7e0b8</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-7699e2dbb81f</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-04067e028764</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (Kurucz 2005) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-0e50a7927295</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-2755c55a0874</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Amarsi) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-amarsi2020_galah\">[5]</a> <small><code>Na-products-352e51858fa7</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D NLTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-aa11fabbd085</code></small></li><li>red-optical · Kitt Peak (1984, molecfit) · Na I · Codex-graded lines · 1D LTE (Gerber) · <a href=\"#ref-asplund2021\">[1]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-lodders2025\">[2]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-nist_asd\">[3]</a>, <a href=\"#ref-gerber2023\">[4]</a> <small><code>Na-products-af83ab9b05b0</code></small></li></ul></details><details open><summary>Complete applicable bibliography</summary><h3>Solar abundance and indicator analyses</h3><ul><li id=\"ref-asplund2021\"><strong>[1]</strong> — <a href=\"https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202140445\">Asplund, M.; Amarsi, A. M.; Grevesse, N. (2021). The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision. A&amp;A 653, A141</a> DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202140445. <a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/refs/bibliography.csv\">source record</a></li><li id=\"ref-lodders2025\"><strong>[2]</strong> — <a href=\"https://doi.org/10.1007/s11214-025-01146-w\">Lodders, K.; Bergemann, M.; Palme, H. (2025). Solar System Elemental Abundances from the Solar Photosphere and CI-Chondrites. Space Science Reviews 221</a> DOI: 10.1007/s11214-025-01146-w. <a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/refs/bibliography.csv\">source record</a></li></ul><h3>Atomic data and gf authorities</h3><ul><li id=\"ref-nist_asd\"><strong>[3]</strong> — <a href=\"https://doi.org/10.18434/T4W30F\">Kramida, A.; Ralchenko, Yu.; Reader, J.; NIST ASD Team (2024). NIST Atomic Spectra Database (version 5.11/5.12). National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD</a> DOI: 10.18434/T4W30F. <a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/refs/bibliography.csv\">source record</a></li></ul><h3>Model and grid sources</h3><ul><li id=\"ref-gerber2023\"><strong>[4]</strong> — <a href=\"https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202243673\">Gerber, J. M.; Magg, E.; Plez, B.; Bergemann, M.; Heiter, U.; Olander, T.; Hoppe, R. (2023). Non-LTE radiative transfer with Turbospectrum. A&amp;A 669, A43</a> DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202243673. <a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/refs/bibliography.csv\">source record</a></li><li id=\"ref-amarsi2020_galah\"><strong>[5]</strong> — <a href=\"https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/abs/2020/10/aa38650-20/aa38650-20.html\">Amarsi, A. M.; Lind, K.; Osorio, Y.; Nordlander, T.; Bergemann, M.; et al. (2020). The GALAH Survey: non-LTE departure coefficients for large spectroscopic surveys. A&amp;A 642, A62</a> DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202038650. <a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/refs/bibliography.csv\">source record</a></li><li id=\"ref-canocchi2026\"><strong>[6]</strong> — <a href=\"https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22975\">Canocchi, G.; Wang, E. X.; Amarsi, A. M.; Lind, K.; Racca, M. (2026). 3D NLTE Sodium abundances in late-type stars. arXiv 2603.22975</a> DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19201830. <a href=\"https://github.com/damienabraxas/exoplanetcodex/blob/e76c06c6173928306b433a805509e63a1a206c71/data/refs/bibliography.csv\">source record</a></li></ul></details></section>",
  "references": [
    {
      "id": "asplund2021",
      "citation": "Asplund, M.; Amarsi, A. M.; Grevesse, N. (2021). The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision. A&A 653, A141",
      "doi": "10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202140445",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "data/refs/bibliography.csv",
          "record": "asplund2021"
        }
      ],
      "layers": [
        "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
        "Model and grid sources",
        "Atomic data and gf authorities"
      ],
      "roles": [
        "Solar Na comparison literature; not an adopted Codex abundance.",
        "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
        "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
        "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
        "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage)."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "lodders2025",
      "citation": "Lodders, K.; Bergemann, M.; Palme, H. (2025). Solar System Elemental Abundances from the Solar Photosphere and CI-Chondrites. Space Science Reviews 221",
      "doi": "10.1007/s11214-025-01146-w",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11214-025-01146-w",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "data/refs/bibliography.csv",
          "record": "lodders2025"
        }
      ],
      "layers": [
        "Solar abundance and indicator analyses"
      ],
      "roles": [
        "Solar Na comparison literature; not an adopted Codex abundance."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "nist_asd",
      "citation": "Kramida, A.; Ralchenko, Yu.; Reader, J.; NIST ASD Team (2024). NIST Atomic Spectra Database (version 5.11/5.12). National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD",
      "doi": "10.18434/T4W30F",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.18434/T4W30F",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "data/refs/bibliography.csv",
          "record": "nist_asd"
        }
      ],
      "layers": [
        "Atomic data and gf authorities"
      ],
      "roles": [
        "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage)."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "gerber2023",
      "citation": "Gerber, J. M.; Magg, E.; Plez, B.; Bergemann, M.; Heiter, U.; Olander, T.; Hoppe, R. (2023). Non-LTE radiative transfer with Turbospectrum. A&A 669, A43",
      "doi": "10.1051/0004-6361/202243673",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202243673",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "data/refs/bibliography.csv",
          "record": "gerber2023"
        }
      ],
      "layers": [
        "Model and grid sources"
      ],
      "roles": [
        "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
        "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
        "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "amarsi2020_galah",
      "citation": "Amarsi, A. M.; Lind, K.; Osorio, Y.; Nordlander, T.; Bergemann, M.; et al. (2020). The GALAH Survey: non-LTE departure coefficients for large spectroscopic surveys. A&A 642, A62",
      "doi": "10.1051/0004-6361/202038650",
      "url": "https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/abs/2020/10/aa38650-20/aa38650-20.html",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "data/refs/bibliography.csv",
          "record": "amarsi2020_galah"
        }
      ],
      "layers": [
        "Model and grid sources"
      ],
      "roles": [
        "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "canocchi2026",
      "citation": "Canocchi, G.; Wang, E. X.; Amarsi, A. M.; Lind, K.; Racca, M. (2026). 3D NLTE Sodium abundances in late-type stars. arXiv 2603.22975",
      "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.19201830",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.22975",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "data/refs/bibliography.csv",
          "record": "canocchi2026"
        }
      ],
      "layers": [
        "Model and grid sources"
      ],
      "roles": [
        "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "reference_bindings": [
    {
      "subject": "element-context",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025"
      ],
      "claim": "Solar Na comparison literature; not an adopted Codex abundance.",
      "evidence": [
        "data/refs/bibliography.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-fb210d1eee02",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-fb210d1eee02",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-a80b76db5d6a",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-a80b76db5d6a",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c047829fd0f2",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c047829fd0f2",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0552befecb14",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0552befecb14",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-4f1dee816393",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-4f1dee816393",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-caab8cbc99e0",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-caab8cbc99e0",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-1229a0a156f8",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-1229a0a156f8",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f1c4ef0ec48e",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f1c4ef0ec48e",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-65e9578f5f35",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-65e9578f5f35",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-448c77475a54",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-448c77475a54",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-85aee27b99bb",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-85aee27b99bb",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-118aa2ad0c1e",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-118aa2ad0c1e",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-81eca203f5c6",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-81eca203f5c6",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6637f12ec02e",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6637f12ec02e",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-18e5094f3c43",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-18e5094f3c43",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-18e5094f3c43",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c474eb26f3ae",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c474eb26f3ae",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c474eb26f3ae",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bb8baa1178c8",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bb8baa1178c8",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bb8baa1178c8",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bf2a2938353f",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bf2a2938353f",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bf2a2938353f",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-dc40cd57490f",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-dc40cd57490f",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-dc40cd57490f",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bdcd99128c04",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bdcd99128c04",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bd12d76eaf22",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bd12d76eaf22",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c0ce41acfee8",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c0ce41acfee8",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-186caf770fd6",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-186caf770fd6",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-65aef47bc520",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-65aef47bc520",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-65aef47bc520",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-d70898a6d4f2",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-d70898a6d4f2",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-d70898a6d4f2",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-9439cb57fb7e",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-9439cb57fb7e",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-9439cb57fb7e",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-5919b5d71e97",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-5919b5d71e97",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-5919b5d71e97",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-ab243f5f7fb7",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-ab243f5f7fb7",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-cd4f141ff187",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-cd4f141ff187",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-77cd03c01180",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-77cd03c01180",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-252fafda80c1",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-252fafda80c1",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f7b85afbd89a",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f7b85afbd89a",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-4c88219f1ea2",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-4c88219f1ea2",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-034d202da814",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-034d202da814",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-1a483ec17b8d",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-1a483ec17b8d",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-a3583bba6864",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-a3583bba6864",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-abce6000c004",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-abce6000c004",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b06ed066892d",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b06ed066892d",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b06ed066892d",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-620b8337a6f5",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-620b8337a6f5",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-620b8337a6f5",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b90c5f56677b",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b90c5f56677b",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b90c5f56677b",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c00f6af0b401",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c00f6af0b401",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-c00f6af0b401",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-3549f0317ecb",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-3549f0317ecb",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-841d473766d8",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-841d473766d8",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b72a4b06a2c1",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b72a4b06a2c1",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b1a83c053f0b",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-b1a83c053f0b",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-58dd461d3e5a",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-58dd461d3e5a",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-5a5ee22946b5",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-5a5ee22946b5",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-be7b30000a66",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-be7b30000a66",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-23bfd23782d9",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-23bfd23782d9",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-17cc53288fb1",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-17cc53288fb1",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-36b16e0d3bcd",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-36b16e0d3bcd",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bf622c820458",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bf622c820458",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-bf622c820458",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-fd002196b613",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-fd002196b613",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-fd002196b613",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0276917cf012",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0276917cf012",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0276917cf012",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6d05db230769",
      "layer": "Solar abundance and indicator analyses",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Published line set NA_AGSS21 (the line selection).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/line_sets/REGISTRY.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6d05db230769",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6d05db230769",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-dd0066591b38",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-dd0066591b38",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-eb26cb8b60bb",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-eb26cb8b60bb",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6f4bd45a4765",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6f4bd45a4765",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-a5cee5792af3",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-a5cee5792af3",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-93bab5e00805",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-93bab5e00805",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-eeac09562b71",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-eeac09562b71",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f8e30b062164",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-f8e30b062164",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv",
        "data/reference/na_canocchi2026/na_canocchi2026_solar.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6f7a1bf44b76",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-6f7a1bf44b76",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021"
      ],
      "claim": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte",
      "evidence": [
        "data/reference/solar_nlte_tables.yaml",
        "data/reference/na_agss21/na_agss21_lines.csv"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-8260a258557d",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-8260a258557d",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-aac4173b0ef6",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-aac4173b0ef6",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-4d5f9acb10d8",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-4d5f9acb10d8",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0c24e0ee234b",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0c24e0ee234b",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-9e68e7906843",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-9e68e7906843",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-32c8f839e09e",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-32c8f839e09e",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-860f6a57a0ff",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-860f6a57a0ff",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-9ac31d7523ad",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-9ac31d7523ad",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-17a68269f94a",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-17a68269f94a",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-8da873b08ed4",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-8da873b08ed4",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-490ef3c9753d",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-490ef3c9753d",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-29aa33878906",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-29aa33878906",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-81cf47912679",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-81cf47912679",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-256c3fc7e0b8",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-256c3fc7e0b8",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-7699e2dbb81f",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-7699e2dbb81f",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-04067e028764",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-04067e028764",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0e50a7927295",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-0e50a7927295",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-2755c55a0874",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-2755c55a0874",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/band_products.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-352e51858fa7",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-352e51858fa7",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.prov.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-aa11fabbd085",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-aa11fabbd085",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-af83ab9b05b0",
      "layer": "Atomic data and gf authorities",
      "reference_ids": [
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "claim": "Na I oscillator strengths of this pool, as the product's own uncertainty budget records them (with their lineage).",
      "evidence": [
        "data/products/solar/Na.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "subject": "Na-products-af83ab9b05b0",
      "layer": "Model and grid sources",
      "reference_ids": [
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "claim": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity.",
      "evidence": [
        "pipeline/gerber_nlte.py"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "product_sources": [
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-fb210d1eee02",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 0,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "H",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a80b76db5d6a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 1,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "H",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c047829fd0f2",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 2,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "H",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0552befecb14",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 3,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4f1dee816393",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 4,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-caab8cbc99e0",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 5,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-1229a0a156f8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 6,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f1c4ef0ec48e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 7,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-65e9578f5f35",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 8,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-448c77475a54",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 9,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-85aee27b99bb",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 10,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-118aa2ad0c1e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 11,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-81eca203f5c6",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 12,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6637f12ec02e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 13,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-18e5094f3c43",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 14,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c474eb26f3ae",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 15,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bb8baa1178c8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 16,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bf2a2938353f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 17,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-dc40cd57490f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 18,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bdcd99128c04",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 19,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bd12d76eaf22",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 20,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c0ce41acfee8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 21,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-186caf770fd6",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 22,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-65aef47bc520",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 23,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 24,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-d70898a6d4f2",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 25,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9439cb57fb7e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 26,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-5919b5d71e97",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 27,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-ab243f5f7fb7",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 28,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-cd4f141ff187",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 29,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-77cd03c01180",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 30,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-252fafda80c1",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 31,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f7b85afbd89a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 32,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4c88219f1ea2",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 33,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-034d202da814",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 34,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-1a483ec17b8d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 35,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a3583bba6864",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 36,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-abce6000c004",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 37,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b06ed066892d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 38,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-620b8337a6f5",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 39,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 40,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b90c5f56677b",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 41,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c00f6af0b401",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 42,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-3549f0317ecb",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 43,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-841d473766d8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 44,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b72a4b06a2c1",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 45,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b1a83c053f0b",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 46,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-58dd461d3e5a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 47,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-5a5ee22946b5",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 48,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-be7b30000a66",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 49,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-23bfd23782d9",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 50,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-17cc53288fb1",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 51,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-36b16e0d3bcd",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 52,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bf622c820458",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 53,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 54,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-fd002196b613",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 55,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0276917cf012",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 56,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6d05db230769",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 57,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-dd0066591b38",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 58,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-eb26cb8b60bb",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 59,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6f4bd45a4765",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 60,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a5cee5792af3",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 61,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-93bab5e00805",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 62,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-eeac09562b71",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 63,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f8e30b062164",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 64,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "canocchi2026"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte, A_1d_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6f7a1bf44b76",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 65,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd"
      ],
      "model_note": "Cited solar abundance differences from the published model columns, applied additively to our LTE fits; not a new in-transfer 3D calculation. Baseline atmosphere: A_marcs_lte"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-8260a258557d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 66,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-aac4173b0ef6",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 67,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4d5f9acb10d8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 68,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0c24e0ee234b",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 69,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9e68e7906843",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 70,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-32c8f839e09e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 71,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-860f6a57a0ff",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 72,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9ac31d7523ad",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 73,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-17a68269f94a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 74,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-8da873b08ed4",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 75,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-490ef3c9753d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 76,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-29aa33878906",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 77,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-81cf47912679",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 78,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-256c3fc7e0b8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 79,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-7699e2dbb81f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 80,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-04067e028764",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 81,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0e50a7927295",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 82,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-2755c55a0874",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 83,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D-LTE synthesis (Turbospectrum); no NLTE/3D correction claimed."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-352e51858fa7",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 84,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "amarsi2020_galah"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: 1D NLTE, per-line correction from the Amarsi 2020 GALAH departure grid via PySME (data/nlte_grids/Na_Amarsi2020_PySME.csv)."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-aa11fabbd085",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 85,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: ENGINE-B-NLTE; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-af83ab9b05b0",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 86,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "reference_ids": [
        "asplund2021",
        "lodders2025",
        "nist_asd",
        "gerber2023"
      ],
      "model_note": "Feed treatment: synth-1D-LTE-gerber; Turbospectrum on the registered Gerber deck. The product retains its own atmosphere and ion identity."
    }
  ],
  "visibility_audit": [
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-fb210d1eee02",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 0,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "H",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a80b76db5d6a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 1,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "H",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c047829fd0f2",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 2,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "H",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_h_rya1094",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0552befecb14",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 3,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4f1dee816393",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 4,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-caab8cbc99e0",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 5,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-1229a0a156f8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 6,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f1c4ef0ec48e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 7,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-65e9578f5f35",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 8,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-448c77475a54",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 9,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_j_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-85aee27b99bb",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 10,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-118aa2ad0c1e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 11,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-81eca203f5c6",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 12,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6637f12ec02e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 13,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_y_wide_rya1054",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-18e5094f3c43",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 14,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c474eb26f3ae",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 15,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bb8baa1178c8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 16,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bf2a2938353f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 17,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-dc40cd57490f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 18,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bdcd99128c04",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 19,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bd12d76eaf22",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 20,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c0ce41acfee8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 21,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-186caf770fd6",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 22,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-65aef47bc520",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 23,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0bac2ebdc4ba",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 24,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-d70898a6d4f2",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 25,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9439cb57fb7e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 26,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-5919b5d71e97",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 27,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-ab243f5f7fb7",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 28,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-cd4f141ff187",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 29,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-77cd03c01180",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 30,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-252fafda80c1",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 31,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f7b85afbd89a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 32,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4c88219f1ea2",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 33,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-034d202da814",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 34,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-1a483ec17b8d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 35,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a3583bba6864",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 36,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-abce6000c004",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 37,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b06ed066892d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 38,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-620b8337a6f5",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 39,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-69a7aa7bb39f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 40,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b90c5f56677b",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 41,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-c00f6af0b401",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 42,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-3549f0317ecb",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 43,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-841d473766d8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 44,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b72a4b06a2c1",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 45,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-b1a83c053f0b",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 46,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-58dd461d3e5a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 47,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-5a5ee22946b5",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 48,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-be7b30000a66",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 49,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-23bfd23782d9",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 50,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-17cc53288fb1",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 51,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-36b16e0d3bcd",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 52,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-bf622c820458",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 53,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f0d7d3616c1c",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 54,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-fd002196b613",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 55,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0276917cf012",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 56,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6d05db230769",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 57,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-dd0066591b38",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 58,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-eb26cb8b60bb",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 59,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6f4bd45a4765",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 60,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-a5cee5792af3",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 61,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-93bab5e00805",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 62,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-eeac09562b71",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 63,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-f8e30b062164",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 64,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-6f7a1bf44b76",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 65,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-8260a258557d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 66,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-aac4173b0ef6",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 67,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-4d5f9acb10d8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 68,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0c24e0ee234b",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 69,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9e68e7906843",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 70,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-32c8f839e09e",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 71,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-860f6a57a0ff",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 72,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-9ac31d7523ad",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 73,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-17a68269f94a",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 74,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-8da873b08ed4",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 75,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "near-UV",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-490ef3c9753d",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 76,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-29aa33878906",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 77,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-81cf47912679",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 78,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-256c3fc7e0b8",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 79,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-7699e2dbb81f",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 80,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-04067e028764",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 81,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-0e50a7927295",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 82,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-2755c55a0874",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 83,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-352e51858fa7",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 84,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-aa11fabbd085",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 85,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-products-af83ab9b05b0",
      "source_bucket": "products",
      "source_index": 86,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "products",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": true,
      "omission_reason": ""
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-e0d2dd2a2a1c",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 0,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-9048e10e7890",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 1,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "NIR",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-edfffb497ed5",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 2,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-0552befecb14",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 3,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "K",
        "instrument": "crires_plus",
        "holding": "solar_crires_plus_k_rya1219",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-76dceefd4ec8",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 4,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-37bef82bacb8",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 5,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-2678e171b20c",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 6,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-4a0fbc6563cc",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 7,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-d6c1db268df0",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 8,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-03e0cba69e58",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 9,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-7fb51681a17f",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 10,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-ce39a1d17239",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 11,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-42ca1bc69b3c",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 12,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-66fd0291423a",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 13,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "red-optical",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-f71c58c6c295",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 14,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-e8146ba54265",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 15,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-f584c8105cb1",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 16,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-30c93b11e986",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 17,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-e9e0ecf4ef2e",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 18,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-cabd428182d5",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 19,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-2f1fc58dc227",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 20,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-50a6e1e9c17d",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 21,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-4d9193c9e90e",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 22,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-f5b73b02734e",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 23,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-0b750b31db35",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 24,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-b4b6a4bbb65e",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 25,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-490dcce2e1c0",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 26,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-054db679d9fd",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 27,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-3a373250d37d",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 28,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag_reiners2016",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-95c20270d0f1",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 29,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-3a6747f0a271",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 30,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-7bf8215315b2",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 31,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-f1a644b36115",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 32,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-fc32596a2fba",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 33,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-84c5054c851c",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 34,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-30f9d192d856",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 35,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-2ab6324bb582",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 36,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-bc232c875269",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 37,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-c91f7a662040",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 38,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "DEEPGRADED",
        "selector": "DEEPGRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-7dae89f8bf92",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 39,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-a416cb92f775",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 40,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-8c816fd66e2d",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 41,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-1bb9d4490dca",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 42,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-8e1578e4f82b",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 43,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "iag_fts_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_iag",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-5b334326504c",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 44,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-3557634bc4b9",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 45,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-f5611f34f8fb",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 46,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-4c5346b8d6fc",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 47,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-bb876342781b",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 48,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-777d023bcb74",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 49,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-464fbf877200",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 50,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-ff89363d8989",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 51,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "ALL",
        "selector": "SET-NA_AGSS21",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-0ecf54b93d8d",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 52,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-16830cde73b5",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 53,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-aa9cdb3ba020",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 54,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-cdaed62866de",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 55,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-6ade32a50b81",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 56,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-f1a7e5abec03",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 57,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-6287e1d38674",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 58,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_kurucz2005_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-6abf48ab5738",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 59,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-ce9aad0687fe",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 60,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-8ffe1e5ac153",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 61,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-cf2dcf2bc301",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 62,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-f9f7f7013e6c",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 63,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "kpno_solar_atlas",
        "holding": "solar_kpno_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-a80be9502843",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 64,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "synth-1D-LTE-gerber",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-570909e62f78",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 65,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-B-NLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-9e23e450ff13",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 66,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "1D-LTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-6d07b5478c06",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 67,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A-3DNLTE",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    },
    {
      "publication_id": "Na-archive-36535746b658",
      "source_bucket": "archive",
      "source_index": 68,
      "identity": {
        "element": "Na",
        "ion": "I",
        "band": "VIS",
        "instrument": "harps",
        "holding": "solar_harps_molecfit_corrected",
        "tier": "GRADED",
        "selector": "GRADED",
        "route": "SYNTH",
        "treatment": "ENGINE-A",
        "line_set": null,
        "indicator": null
      },
      "disposition": "archive",
      "quarantine_codes": [],
      "visible": false,
      "omission_reason": "archive: not a current admitted product"
    }
  ],
  "highlighted_products": []
}
